The Army and Politics in Indonesia

The book is widely lauded as a standard, highly readable, and convincing account of elite politics and the transition period from Sukarno to Soeharto. Reviewers highlight its crucial role in understanding key military figures and factions, and its detailed charting of numerous internal military groups and their influence on the nation's life. It is praised for its nuanced approach, integrating broader factors such as economic development and political Islam, and for making a strong case for distinguishing between a specific historical event and a subsequent military power shift. Many consider it an indispensable guide for comprehending the enduring impact of military movements on Indonesia's political landscape.

However, a recurring criticism is that certain sections of the book, particularly the discussion of the G30S event, are considered dated in light of more recent academic research. Some reviewers also found the writing style to lack vibrancy or "color," suggesting that other authors might offer a more engaging read for later historical periods. The overall age of the publication is noted as a potential limitation, implying that some of the information might not reflect the most current scholarship.

Despite these points, the book remains highly recommended as a foundational and essential text for understanding Indonesian history and politics. It continues to serve as a valuable historical map for navigating the intricate dynamics of the military's role and its lasting influence on the nation. This work is particularly suited for students of political systems, historians, and anyone seeking a deep understanding of Indonesia's political development, especially the pervasive and enduring role of its military.