The Brethren Inside the Supreme Court

The book is widely praised as an unparalleled, in-depth, and compelling look into the inner workings of the U.S. Supreme Court, offering an unprecedented glimpse behind its secretive facade. Reviewers consistently highlight its ability to humanize the justices, revealing their personalities, interactions, and the complex politicking that shapes their decisions, making the institution feel less like a "barrister bubble" and more like a human endeavor. Many found it a fascinating and engaging read, often compared to a novel, that illuminates how the Court functions as a distinctly political branch of government. Despite being written decades ago, the book is considered remarkably relevant to contemporary issues, providing valuable historical context for ongoing debates about topics like civil rights, equality, and the Court's role in society. It is lauded for its insightful reporting, offering rare depth to complex arguments and revitalizing discussions about the proper function of the judiciary.

While largely positive, the reviews also present several criticisms and areas of concern. A recurring point is the unflattering portrayal of Chief Justice Burger, who is often depicted as manipulative, intellectually insecure, and overly concerned with control, leading some to question the objectivity of this characterization, especially given the authors' journalistic background. Other justices are also shown with significant flaws, including personal squabbles, shifting positions, and prioritizing personal opinions over legal principles. Some readers felt the book occasionally lacked clarity for those without a legal background, assuming knowledge of certain legal terms without adequate explanation. Minor criticisms include a perceived overemphasis on certain cases, a disorganized narrative style in places, and chapters that were considered too lengthy. A few reviewers also found the inclusion of certain personal anecdotes about the justices, such as their reactions to obscenity cases, to be superfluous or voyeuristic.

Ultimately, "The Brethren" is considered a classic and an essential read for anyone interested in American history, the legal system, or the Supreme Court itself. It is highly recommended for law students, legal professionals, and intellectually curious readers seeking a candid, behind-the-scenes understanding of how judicial decisions are truly made. While it may not instill confidence or "warm fuzzies" about the impartiality of the Court, it offers an eye-opening and often entertaining perspective that challenges preconceived notions about the institution. The book provides crucial context for understanding both past landmark rulings and the ongoing dynamics of the modern Court, making it a valuable resource for those who wish to delve deeper into the personalities and politics that shape one of the most powerful branches of government.