The Case-Book of Sherlock Holmes (Old Fashion)

Name: The Case-Book of Sherlock Holmes (Old Fashion)
Rating: 8.22 (31502 reviews)
Author: A. Conan Doyle
ISBN: 9798687958189

par

Langue: Anglais
Publié en: 2020
Maison d'édition: Independently published
Pages: 223
ISBN: 9798687958189

Thèmes

Infos sur l'édition originale

The Case-Book of Sherlock Holmes Paru initialement en 1927

Langue d'origine

Anglais

Éditeur d'origine John Murray, 1927

Autres éditions (243)

Casebook of Sherlock Holmes Annotated

2020 • Independently Published

Anglais

Casebook of Sherlock Holmes Annotated Edition

2021 • Independently Published

Anglais

The Case-Book of Sherlock Holmes (100th Anniversary Edition): With 65 Original Illustrations

2023 • SeaWolf Press

Anglais

The Case-Book of Sherlock Holmes (100th Anniversary Edition): With 65 Original Illustrations

2023 • SeaWolf Press

Anglais

The Case Book Of Sherlock Holmes: Annotated

2017 • Independently Published

Anglais

8.22 / 10 (31K notes)

Résumé des avis

Les plus

The Case-Book of Sherlock Holmes, the final collection of short stories featuring the iconic detective, is largely celebrated for its continued entertainment value and the lasting appeal of its central characters. Reviewers found many of the tales to be engaging and well-crafted, offering a variety of unique and strange cases that kept them captivated. Highlights often include stories praised for their cleverness, intricate puzzles, and the distinct narrative shifts where Holmes himself or a third-person narrator takes the helm, providing a fresh perspective on the detective's methods and personality. Readers particularly appreciated moments that revealed a deeper, more emotional side of Holmes, showcasing his genuine feelings and his enduring bond with Dr. Watson, alongside his characteristic wit and humor.

Les moins

However, the collection is also frequently described as uneven, often considered the weakest among the Sherlock Holmes anthologies. Critics note a reliance on "gimmickry" and plots that sometimes feel like "retreads" of earlier, more original stories. Some solutions are deemed far-fetched or less grounded in Holmes's usual deductive brilliance. The quality of individual stories varies considerably, with some being singled out as particularly disappointing or even "ludicrous." Certain narratives where Holmes takes over from Watson are sometimes felt to lack the familiar dynamic and charm. Furthermore, modern readers have pointed out the presence of outdated racial stereotypes and problematic language, which can detract from the reading experience.

Conclusion

Despite these criticisms, The Case-Book of Sherlock Holmes remains an essential read for dedicated fans looking to complete the entire canon. While it may not consistently reach the heights of earlier collections, it offers a bittersweet farewell to beloved characters and provides unique insights into their world. This book is best suited for long-time Sherlock Holmes enthusiasts, readers interested in the evolution of Arthur Conan Doyle's writing, and those who appreciate classic mystery short stories, understanding that some elements reflect the historical context in which they were written. It serves as a final, memorable journey into the "fairy kingdom of romance" that Doyle created.

Pas encore d'avis. Sois le premier à en donner un !

Sources des notes

Thèmes

Infos sur l'édition originale

Autres éditions (243)

Casebook of Sherlock Holmes Annotated

Casebook of Sherlock Holmes Annotated Edition

The Case-Book of Sherlock Holmes (100th Anniversary Edition): With 65 Original Illustrations

The Case-Book of Sherlock Holmes (100th Anniversary Edition): With 65 Original Illustrations

The Case Book Of Sherlock Holmes: Annotated