Positives Tony Attwood's "The Complete Guide to Asperger's Syndrome" is widely praised as an excellent and detailed resource for understanding the complexities of the condition. Many readers, including those who have been diagnosed as adults or are seeking diagnosis, found it highly illuminating for self-recognition and gaining a clearer understanding of their own experiences or those of loved ones. Reviewers appreciate its thorough description of how Asperger's manifests, covering characteristics, symptoms, and associated issues across various life stages from childhood to adulthood. The book is lauded for providing logical explanations for behaviors, offering valuable insights for parents, teachers, and carers, and highlighting the unique strengths often found in individuals with Asperger's. Its comprehensive overview of diagnostic guidelines and traditional support approaches is frequently cited as a significant positive.
Negatives Despite its title, a recurring criticism is that the book is not truly "complete" and is often considered outdated in certain areas, particularly concerning the DSM-V diagnostic criteria and current understandings within the autistic community. A major point of contention is its overwhelming focus on children and adolescents, with many adult readers finding the suggested strategies simplistic or less applicable to their own lives. The writing style is frequently described as dry, academic, or "textbook-drone," making it a challenging or even depressing read for some. Several reviewers also raise concerns about problematic portrayals of gender and sexuality, the use of "normal" for neurotypical individuals, and an emphasis on deficits and problems that can reinforce negative stereotypes or suggest harmful masking behaviors.
Conclusion Overall, the book serves as a valuable and informative foundational guide, particularly for parents, teachers, and professionals seeking a detailed introduction to Asperger's Syndrome in children and adolescents. While adults with Asperger's may find sections illuminating for self-understanding, they should be prepared for a predominantly child-focused perspective and potentially challenging insights. Readers looking for the most current research, nuanced community perspectives, or extensive practical strategies specifically tailored for adults might find the book falls short of its ambitious title, but it remains a widely recommended starting point for a deeper understanding of the condition.
