Hannah Wells, a focused music major, confidently navigates her academic life, yet her past makes romantic connections a significant challenge. Garrett Graham, the charismatic captain of the hockey team, faces a threat to his athletic career as his grades plummet in a crucial philosophy class. His only option is to seek help from the one student who aced the midterm: Hannah.
A deal is proposed: Hannah will tutor Garrett to save his GPA, and in exchange, he will pretend to be her boyfriend to capture the attention of her crush. This strategic arrangement at Briar University soon develops beyond initial expectations, revealing an unforeseen connection and undeniable chemistry. As their fake relationship progresses, both Hannah and Garrett must confront personal histories and vulnerabilities, blurring the lines between their agreement and genuine feelings.
The rigid structure of Briar University often felt like a cage to Hannah Wells, a talented music major whose scholarship demanded unwavering focus. She moved through her days with a quiet determination, her mind sharp in the classroom, but a different kind of confidence eluded her, especially when it came to matters of the heart. A past trauma, a shadow from her teenage years, had left her wary, particularly of physical intimacy, despite her outward composure. Yet, a flicker of interest had caught her eye: Justin Kohl, a football player whose presence made her wish she could shed her inhibitions and truly be seen.
Meanwhile, Garrett Graham, the cocky, charismatic captain of the hockey team, found his own aspirations teetering on the edge. His stellar performance on the ice was legendary, but his academic record, specifically a failing grade in a crucial philosophy ethics class, threatened to bench him permanently. Professional hockey after graduation was his singular goal, and he wasn't about to let a textbook stand in his way. Desperate, he sought out the one person who had aced the notorious exam: Hannah Wells.
Their worlds, seemingly disparate, collided with a proposition. Garrett, with his charming arrogance, proposed a deal: Hannah would tutor him, ensuring his eligibility to play, and in return, he would help her capture Justin Kohl's attention. A fake relationship, he reasoned, was the perfect bait, a way to make her crush jealous and finally notice her. Hannah, despite her initial skepticism and Garrett's infuriating confidence, found herself agreeing, stepping out of her comfort zone with a hesitant hope that this unconventional arrangement might just work.
As their tutoring sessions began, crammed into dorm rooms and quiet corners of the campus, the lines between their agreement and reality began to blur. Garrett, beneath his playful teasing and "manwhoring reputation," revealed layers of kindness, loyalty, and a surprising understanding that chipped away at Hannah's defenses. He saw past her quiet exterior to the sharp wit and resilient spirit within. Their banter, initially a shield, soon became a bridge, sparking an undeniable chemistry that sizzled between them, catching both of them off guard.
An unexpected kiss ignited a fire neither had anticipated, proving that their pretend dates held a very real, potent attraction. The physical connection was intense, unlike anything Hannah had experienced, but her past trauma still lingered, a quiet fear that made true vulnerability daunting. Garrett, however, proved to be more than just a cocky jock. He was patient, sensitive, and fiercely protective, creating a safe space where Hannah could slowly, tentatively, begin to confront her fears and trust again.
Their relationship deepened, evolving from a transactional arrangement into something profoundly genuine. They leaned on each other, sharing secrets and vulnerabilities that neither had dared to expose before. Hannah found strength in Garrett's unwavering support, and he, in turn, discovered a depth of feeling that transcended his hockey ambitions. The deal that had brought them together had inadvertently forged a bond of love, trust, and mutual understanding, proving that sometimes, the most unexpected paths lead to the truest connections.
What other readers say
Liked
This book has been widely praised by many readers for its highly entertaining and addictive qualities, often leading to quick completion. Reviewers frequently highlighted the strong chemistry and witty banter between the main characters, Hannah and Garrett, as a major draw. The gradual development of their "fake dating" relationship into a genuine connection was a particular favorite. Garrett, despite an initial "bad boy" image, was often described as charming, caring, and sweet, while Hannah was appreciated for her intelligence, confidence, and resilience. Fans enjoyed the book as a fun, sexy, and heartfelt New Adult romance that effectively utilizes popular genre tropes.
Disliked
Conversely, a significant number of reviews expressed strong criticism regarding problematic themes and character behavior. Garrett's actions were frequently labeled as coercive, disrespectful, and manipulative, especially his persistence in pursuing Hannah and his tendency to objectify women. Critics pointed out instances of cringeworthy and unrealistic dialogue, alongside the perpetuation of gender stereotypes, internalized misogyny, and a "boys will be boys" attitude that the narrative often failed to adequately challenge. Concerns were also raised about the handling of sensitive topics, with some finding the protagonist's past trauma addressed insensitively, particularly through a narrative where a male character is perceived as "fixing" her. One review also highlighted the inclusion of a philosophy paper discussing justifications for deeply controversial historical events as particularly insensitive.
In short
Overall, opinions on this book are sharply divided, reflecting its polarizing nature. While not universally acclaimed for literary depth, it is celebrated by its fans for its fast-paced, trope-filled narrative and engaging romantic connection. The book is likely to appeal to readers who enjoy college sports romance, especially the "fake dating" trope, and who prioritize witty banter and a compelling romantic journey, even if it means overlooking some of the more controversial aspects. However, readers sensitive to outdated gender dynamics, coercive male leads, or potentially superficial handling of serious themes may find the book off-putting or frustrating.