The Falls

Reviewers consistently praise the book's deep characterizations, particularly of Inspector Rebus, highlighting his realistic flaws, analytical mind, and engaging personality. The dynamic between Rebus and his colleague Siobhan is also appreciated, showing their individual growth and professional challenges, alongside compelling descriptions of police office politics. The narrative is noted for its intricate plotting, weaving together multiple storylines that demand the reader's attention and build to surprising developments. Unique mystery elements, such as an online game and historical clues involving miniature coffins, are frequently cited as captivating. Furthermore, the book is lauded for its strong sense of place, with Edinburgh itself acting as a vivid character, and for the author's consistent high quality of writing and pacing within the long-running series.

Despite its strengths, some readers found the book's intricate plot to be overly long or slow in parts, with multiple storylines that don't always feel connected until later. A few reviewers noted that certain aspects of the mystery, particularly some solutions, felt predictable or lacking in depth, and that some plot threads were not fully resolved by the end. Specific criticisms included the online game element eventually becoming "absurd" for one reader, and another finding Rebus's recurring struggles tiresome. Some also felt the writing occasionally lacked its usual snappy dialogue or incisive description, suggesting it could benefit from a final polish. For audiobook listeners, issues with the narration and the use of condensed versions were also points of contention.

Overall, "The Falls" is largely considered a strong entry in the Rebus series, with many reviewers calling it one of the best. It is recommended for readers who appreciate deeply developed characters, particularly the complex and often troubled Inspector Rebus, and those who enjoy intricately plotted mysteries that unfold with a keen sense of atmosphere. While some new readers found it accessible, it is generally suggested that those familiar with earlier books in the series might better appreciate the character arcs and ongoing police dynamics. This novel will appeal to fans of Scottish crime fiction, character-driven thrillers, and stories where the setting plays a significant role in the narrative.