The Great Gilly Hopkins

Many reviewers praise the book for its honesty, heart, and powerful storytelling, often bringing readers into a different way of life. Katherine Paterson is lauded for her well-written prose, strong and realistic characters, and the book's high caliber. Gilly, the protagonist, is frequently described as smart, capable, and tough, with her journey of growth and transformation being a central positive aspect. Readers appreciate that the story avoids a traditional "happy ending," instead offering a more realistic and bittersweet conclusion that resonates deeply, leaving a lasting impression. The book is seen as beautifully illustrating raw emotion and offering profound truths about life, family, and the importance of unconditional acceptance, contributing to its status as a classic of children's literature. It’s also noted for its ability to evoke strong emotions, making some readers laugh and cry while providing a vivid and uncompromising sense of reality.

Despite its strengths, several readers express significant reservations, primarily concerning Gilly's character at the beginning of the book. She is frequently described as a foul-mouthed, arrogant, and manipulative "brat" who exhibits racist behavior, uses offensive language, and makes derogatory comments. Some reviewers feel this content, particularly the racism, has not aged well and might be inappropriate or difficult for younger readers, especially if not discussed with an adult. Concerns are also raised about the ending, which some find overly depressing, hopeless, or too realistic to be suitable for children, with one reviewer feeling it could "break a child's spirit." A few critics found the narrative too pessimistic, arguing it conveys a message that life is simply tough with no real positive outcome. Additionally, some reluctant readers or those not drawn to character-driven stories found it hard to engage with, and a few felt the themes of foster care and difficult children, while important, have become repetitive in the genre.

Overall, "The Great Gilly Hopkins" is considered a deeply impactful and complex character study, lauded for its unflinching realism and emotional depth. While its challenging themes and protagonist's initial behavior make it unsuitable for all young readers or those seeking a lighthearted tale, many believe it offers valuable lessons on empathy, resilience, and the power of love and acceptance. It is highly recommended for middle-grade readers, generally ten and older, who are ready to engage with a nuanced and often difficult portrayal of life in the foster care system. Adults also find it a compelling and thought-provoking read, especially those who appreciate a story that doesn't shy away from life's complexities and contradictions, ultimately leaving them with a sense of hope for the protagonist's future, even if not a conventionally "happy" one.