The Guard of the Dead - حارس الموتى Haris al-mawtá

Reviewers widely praise the book for its engaging and captivating narrative, drawing readers into its world from the very first pages. Many found the author's writing style to be smooth, vivid, and deeply atmospheric, creating a powerful sense of place and emotion. The novel is particularly commended for offering a fresh and unique perspective on the Lebanese Civil War, a topic frequently explored in literature, by focusing on the individual human experience amidst the conflict. Themes of fear, survival, and the profound impact of war on human relationships and morality are skillfully explored, with the protagonist's internal journey and observations forming a compelling core. The pacing is often described as fast, making it a book that can be devoured in a short period.

Despite its strengths, some reviewers felt the book suffered from a lack of narrative novelty, suggesting that the historical material of the Lebanese Civil War has been extensively covered, and the book did not always bring enough new insights. Criticisms also arose regarding the plot and structure, with some finding it loosely connected, lacking a strong, cohesive plot or a deep, engrossing central issue. The ending was a point of contention; while some found its open and ambiguous nature fitting for the subject matter, others were left feeling unsatisfied, describing it as abrupt, unresolved, or even disappointing. Additionally, some readers found certain descriptions to be overly long or unnecessary, while others were uncomfortable with the protagonist's morally questionable actions and the inclusion of disturbing or explicit content.

Overall, the book offers a thought-provoking and often intense reading experience, particularly for those interested in the human toll of the Lebanese Civil War. Its strength lies in its atmospheric writing, unique individual perspective, and exploration of complex themes like fear, survival, and moral compromise. It would appeal to readers who appreciate character-driven narratives that delve into the psychological impact of conflict and are open to less conventional plot structures and ambiguous conclusions. However, readers seeking a traditional narrative with a clear resolution, a deeply original take on war literature, or a protagonist with unblemished morality might find aspects of the book challenging or less satisfying.