The Lost Apothecary
by Sarah Penner
7.52 / 10 494K ratings
- Language
- English
- Published
- 2022
- Publisher
- Park Row Books
- Pages
- 352
- ISBN
- 9780778311973
Hidden in a dark alley in eighteenth-century London, a secret apothecary shop caters to an unusual clientele. The owner, Nella, was once a respected healer but now uses her knowledge for a darker purpose: selling well-disguised poisons to desperate women seeking liberation from the men who have wronged them. She operates under two strict rules: the poison must never be used to harm another woman, and the names of both killer and victim must be recorded in her register. But when a precocious twelve-year-old girl becomes her newest patron, their unexpected friendship sets in motion a chain of events that threatens to expose them all.
Two centuries later, aspiring historian Caroline Parcewell is spending her tenth wedding anniversary alone in London, reeling from a discovery that has shattered her marriage. A chance find during a mudlarking expedition along the River Thames - a small, peculiar glass vial - pulls her into an investigation of a long-forgotten string of murders. As Caroline's search deepens, it connects her story to the apothecary's in unexpected ways, revealing how the choices of women in the past can echo for centuries. This is a story of secrets, vengeance, and the remarkable ways women can save each other across time.
Two centuries later, aspiring historian Caroline Parcewell is spending her tenth wedding anniversary alone in London, reeling from a discovery that has shattered her marriage. A chance find during a mudlarking expedition along the River Thames - a small, peculiar glass vial - pulls her into an investigation of a long-forgotten string of murders. As Caroline's search deepens, it connects her story to the apothecary's in unexpected ways, revealing how the choices of women in the past can echo for centuries. This is a story of secrets, vengeance, and the remarkable ways women can save each other across time.
Subjects
Original edition
The Lost ApothecaryOriginally published in 2021 English Harpercollins
Other editions (13)
What other readers say
Liked
The book is widely praised for its captivating and unique premise, centered around a secret 18th-century apothecary in London that dispenses poisons to women seeking liberation from abusive men. Reviewers were immediately drawn in by the promise of an intriguing mystery and a narrative focused on female empowerment and revenge. Many found the historical setting of 1790s London to be richly atmospheric and immersive, effectively transporting the reader into its bustling streets and hidden corners. The detailed descriptions of poisons and apothecary practices were also appreciated, adding a layer of authenticity to the historical timeline. Several readers commended the author for a strong debut, highlighting the engaging storytelling and the exploration of women's resilience and their efforts to control their destinies, even when separated by centuries.
Disliked
Despite the compelling concept, a significant number of reviewers felt the book ultimately underdelivered on its promise, often describing it as dull, slow-paced, or plodding. A common criticism is directed at the present-day storyline, with many finding the modern protagonist's journey to be uninteresting, unnecessary, or poorly developed, serving primarily as a vehicle for the historical plot. Her actions and character arc were frequently deemed unrealistic or contrived, particularly regarding her academic pursuits and personal relationships. Furthermore, some readers found the historical timeline, despite its potential, lacked the depth, darkness, or suspense they anticipated, feeling that exciting moments were glossed over. The writing style was occasionally criticized for being shallow, relying on telling rather than showing, and for a lack of distinct voices between characters across different eras, leading to implausible plot points and a sense of melodrama.
In short
Overall, the book elicits a polarizing response, appealing strongly to some readers while disappointing others who expected a grittier or more complex narrative. It is best suited for those who appreciate historical fiction with a dual timeline structure, particularly if they are interested in themes of female agency and the hidden lives of women throughout history. Readers who enjoy a more character-driven story of self-discovery set against an atmospheric backdrop, and who are less concerned with strict historical accuracy or intense suspense, are likely to find this a captivating read. However, those seeking a fast-paced thriller, deep moral ambiguity, or meticulously researched historical detail beyond the core concept may find it falls short of their expectations.
No reviews yet. Be the first.





