The Man who Smiled

Many readers praise this installment in the Wallander series for its engaging nature and character depth. Wallander himself is highlighted as a complex and introspective protagonist, grappling with the emotional toll of his work and a deep depression, which offers a refreshing contrast to more action-oriented detectives. Reviewers appreciate the realistic portrayal of police work, with a meticulously constructed plot that is easy to follow despite its complexity. The introduction of a new female detective, Ann-Britt Höglund, is seen as a positive addition, bringing a welcome dynamic to the team. The book is also commended for its strong sense of place, immersing readers in the local Swedish setting with vivid atmospheric descriptions and a palpable sense of the cold, damp environment. Furthermore, the narrative is noted for its suspenseful quality, keeping many readers captivated, and for raising pertinent questions about the future of police forces, corruption, and justice.

Despite its strengths, some reviewers found aspects of the book less compelling. Criticisms include a perceived slowness in pacing, particularly in the middle sections, and an overabundance of minute details regarding times and schedules. The scale of the crimes, involving international financial malfeasance and illicit activities, was seen by some as overly grand or "off the charts" for the small Swedish town setting, stretching the bounds of realism. The main antagonist, while "creepy," was sometimes described as a "cartoonish" or "pantomime" figure, and the mystery surrounding the financial aspects of the crime was not always clearly explained. A few readers felt the plot lacked sufficient red herrings or suspense, as the identity of the culprit was often apparent early on, leading to a predictable progression. Additionally, Wallander's character, while generally praised, was occasionally seen as overly melancholic or his actions (such as a sudden acquisition of "superhero" skills during the climax) as unrealistic.

Overall, "The Man Who Smiled" generally receives a positive reception, especially from established fans of the Kurt Wallander series and Scandinavian crime fiction. It is lauded as a thought-provoking police procedural that excels in character development and atmospheric storytelling, offering a deep dive into the protagonist's psyche. While some find its pacing deliberate and the scope of its villainy a stretch, many appreciate its thematic ambition and the nuanced portrayal of its lead detective. This book would particularly appeal to readers who enjoy character-driven crime novels with a focus on internal struggles and realistic police investigation, who appreciate a strong sense of place, and are comfortable with a more somber, introspective tone rather than fast-paced action thrillers. It is recommended to read the series in order to fully appreciate Wallander's evolving personal journey.