Positives The book is largely praised for its courageous and accessible chronicling of Russian politics and Vladimir Putin's rise to power. Reviewers highlight its well-researched content, which effectively fills gaps in mainstream media coverage and offers valuable context for understanding Putin's background and character. Many found it to be a compelling and eye-opening account of corruption, abuse of power, and the systematic dismantling of democratic institutions in Russia. The author's journalistic background and personal connection to the events are often cited as providing unique insights, making the complex topic engaging and easy to read, with some comparing its narrative style to that of a captivating spy novel.
Negatives Conversely, the book faces criticism for its perceived strong authorial bias, with some reviewers suggesting it is driven by personal animosity towards Vladimir Putin, thus impacting its objectivity. A significant point of contention is the book's reliance on speculation, particularly in its earlier chapters detailing Putin's youth and ascent, where substantiated facts are sometimes seen as replaced by assumptions and anecdotal evidence. Critics also argue that it is not a traditional biography, but rather a collection of essays or a journalistic exposé that sometimes diverges from its central subject to focus on the author's experiences or broader issues of Russian corruption. The writing style is occasionally described as tedious, lacking depth, or presenting unqualified generalizations and conspiracy theories as undisputed truths, further detracting from its perceived factual rigor.
Conclusion Ultimately, the book offers a vivid and often disturbing portrayal of Vladimir Putin's rule and the challenges to democracy in Russia. While acknowledged for its investigative journalism and ability to illuminate underreported events, readers are advised to approach it with an awareness of the author's distinct viewpoint and the speculative nature of certain sections. It is recommended for those seeking an accessible, critical perspective on contemporary Russian politics, particularly individuals interested in the dynamics of political power, human rights, and political corruption. However, readers desiring a strictly objective, deeply analytical, or comprehensive biography of Putin's entire life may find its narrative style and perceived biases less aligned with their expectations.
