Positives Reviewers universally commend this book as an exceptionally practical, wise, and Christ-centered guide for anyone considering or currently involved in pastoral ministry. Many found it to be a profoundly helpful resource, offering clarity, encouragement, and a "compass" for navigating the often ambiguous path of ministry aspiration. Readers highlighted its blend of experiential wisdom and biblical grounding, often noting its superiority to other resources, including some seminary classes. The book is praised for addressing crucial topics such as motives, fitness, and personal life management, and for providing necessary "speed bumps" for reflection. Its short, engaging chapters are described as "gold," packed with sage advice that speaks to the heart, head, and hands, with many expressing a wish they had read it earlier in their journey.
Negatives While overwhelmingly positive, the reviews offer minimal direct criticism of the book itself. The primary observation, rather than a negative, is that the book is explicitly designed for men pursuing vocational pastoral ministry. Consequently, some readers not directly aiming for full-time pastorship noted that certain sections, while still beneficial for understanding the office and growing in general Christian character, were less directly applicable to their specific situations. However, even these readers consistently found the book to be a valuable resource for personal growth and for appreciating the labor of their own pastors.
Conclusion Overall, the book is considered a significant gift to the church, with many reviewers calling it a "must-read" and predicting it will become a classic. Its framework, which often emphasizes "aspiring" to ministry qualifications over a subjective "calling," is particularly appreciated for being both humbling and encouraging. The book effectively challenges readers to grow in godliness and humble service, always centering on the paramount importance of loving Christ above all else. This book is highly recommended for aspiring pastors, current pastors, associate pastors, and lay elders, as well as any Christian man seeking to understand the office of eldership or grow in Christ-like character and service within their local church.
