The seven storey mountain

The reviews frequently praise Thomas Merton's "The Seven Storey Mountain" as a significant and powerful spiritual autobiography, often drawing comparisons to St. Augustine's Confessions. Many readers found Merton to be a gifted and prolific writer, whose prose is described as clean, accessible, beautiful, honest, and compelling. His account of a personal quest for meaning and purpose, leading to his conversion to the Catholic faith, is highlighted as inspiring, uplifting, and deeply human. Reviewers appreciated his vivid descriptions of childhood in Europe and the profound role literature played in his spiritual transformation. The book is lauded for its introspective look into the soul, its rich contemplations on grace, and its ability to offer a sense of interior peace, even acting as a salve for those experiencing personal difficulties. For many, it presents a compelling case for a contemplative life and the interconnectedness of individual spiritual journeys within a larger community.

Despite its acclaim, "The Seven Storey Mountain" garnered criticism for several aspects. Some readers found portions of the book, particularly the initial sections, to be painfully slow or a monotonous read. A recurring point of contention was Merton's spiritual judgments of others, which some reviewers perceived as narrow-minded, bordering on religious bigotry, and at times self-righteous or even mean-spirited. Specific examples included literal interpretations of divine intervention and criticism of other religious practices while presenting Catholic doctrines as self-evident. The book's overtly pro-Catholic stance and perceived "lecturing" tone were off-putting for non-Catholic readers. Some felt Merton's narrative of his pre-conversion life came across as "painfully normal" rather than the "wasted youth" he depicted, leading to accusations of self-indulgence and unresolved internal conflict. Additionally, a few reviewers noted a shift from analytical thought to what they considered superstition or blind faith, and expressed disappointment that the published version omitted certain "worldly" details, making it an incomplete portrayal of Merton's life.

Ultimately, "The Seven Storey Mountain" stands as an important and impactful work in spiritual literature, though it clearly divides opinions. It is not universally recommended, primarily due to its intense focus on Catholic theology and Merton's specific worldview. This book would particularly appeal to readers interested in profound conversion stories, personal spiritual journeys, and the intricacies of monastic life or contemplative spirituality. Those who appreciate well-crafted memoirs, philosophical introspection, and the exploration of faith's transformative power, even if not Catholic themselves, may find it deeply rewarding. However, readers seeking a more secular autobiography, those averse to strong religious pronouncements, or those preferring a less dense and more "relatable" spiritual narrative might find it challenging or disappointing. It remains a significant text for anyone exploring the human search for God and meaning, provided they approach it with an open mind towards its specific religious context.