The Things We Cannot Say
by Kelly Rimmer
9.08 / 10 309K ratings
- Language
- English
- Published
- 2024
- Publisher
- ReadHowYouWant.com, Limited
- Pages
- 618
- ISBN
- 9781038768452
Europe is gripped by war in 1942, and in a small Polish village, Alina Dziak's life with her beloved Tomasz is torn apart by Nazi occupation. As her world fragments, Alina makes a decision that will echo through generations, burying a truth beneath years of silence.
In the present day, Alina's granddaughter, Alice, finds her own life strained by the complexities of family when her grandmother, near the end of her life, reveals a desire for a secret from the past to finally be unearthed. Alice's journey to a distant land to fulfill this request uncovers a story of sacrifice, perseverance, and the enduring power of love, revealing how the choices made in desperate times can shape the future in unexpected ways.
In the present day, Alina's granddaughter, Alice, finds her own life strained by the complexities of family when her grandmother, near the end of her life, reveals a desire for a secret from the past to finally be unearthed. Alice's journey to a distant land to fulfill this request uncovers a story of sacrifice, perseverance, and the enduring power of love, revealing how the choices made in desperate times can shape the future in unexpected ways.
Subjects
- Literature & Fiction
- Genre Fiction
- Suspense
- Literary
- Fiction
- Historical
- World War II
- Romance
- Coming of Age
- Family Life
- Contemporary
- Friendship
- Women's Fiction
- Domestic Life
- Women
- Classics
- Fiction, historical, general
- Historical Fiction
- Adult
- Christian
- Jewish
- War
- Sagas
- Fiction, family life
- Holocaust
- Man-woman relationships, fiction
- Mystery & Detective
- Feminist
- Thrillers
- War & Military
- Multiple Timelines
- Book Club
Original edition
The Things We Cannot SayOriginally published in 2019 English Hachette Australia
Other editions (44)
Listen to the summary Narrated summary
The scent of freshly tilled earth and the distant hum of the village were Alina's world, a world where the future was as clear and bright as the Polish sky. Since she was nine, her heart had belonged to Tomasz, her best friend, now away studying medicine in Warsaw. At fifteen, with an engagement ring on her finger, she dreamt of their wedding, of a life built on their family farm in Trzebinia, dismissing the whispers of Nazi soldiers at the border as distant troubles. But the whispers grew into a roar, and the familiar rhythm of her days shattered. Injustice, brutal and swift, descended, tearing at the fabric of their lives, dividing neighbors with fear and hate.
As the war tightened its relentless grip, Alina's world became one of constant anxiety. Tomasz, her steadfast hope, vanished, leaving behind only a gaping silence that echoed the growing despair. Where she once counted the days until his return, she now measured the spaces between hope and grief, all while navigating the watchful eyes of soldiers patrolling their farm. Survival became a daily struggle, a silent battle fought amidst the ruins of her innocence. Yet, amidst the terror, a desperate choice was made, a lie spoken that would bind her destiny and remain hidden for generations, a secret buried deep within her heart.
Decades later, in a world far removed from war-torn Poland, Alice found herself adrift in a different kind of battle. Her days were a relentless cycle of caring for her seven-year-old son, Eddie, who navigated the world through the lens of autism, and her bright, precocious daughter, Callie. Her marriage, too, felt stretched thin, her husband Wade often distant, absorbed by his career. Then came the call: her beloved Babcia, Alina, had suffered a stroke.
In the sterile quiet of the hospital room, Babcia, unable to speak, communicated through an iPad app, her urgent pleas directed at Alice. A journey to Poland, she insisted, to uncover a long-buried truth, to settle unfinished business that had haunted her for nearly eighty years. Reluctantly, Alice agreed, the weight of her grandmother's unspoken history pressing upon her. This unexpected quest, however, began to shift the dynamics at home, forcing Wade to step into the space Alice had always occupied, to connect with Eddie in ways he hadn't before.
Alice's pilgrimage to Poland unfolded like a detective story, each step bringing her closer to the heart of her grandmother's past. She retraced Alina's harrowing journey, the unimaginable atrocities endured during the Nazi occupation, and the profound sacrifices made for love and survival. She encountered the family of Tomasz's sister, Emilia, who were initially bewildered by Alice's claims, unsure how Alina could be Tomasz's granddaughter given his fate. Yet, the striking resemblance between Alice and the Polish family was undeniable, a living testament to a shared, hidden lineage.
Through Emilia's fragmented memories and Alice's own discoveries, the devastating truth began to emerge. Alina and Tomasz, deeply in love, had been caught in the brutal currents of war, their plans for escape intertwined with their efforts to protect a young Jewish couple and their infant daughter. Tomasz, in an act of extraordinary self-sacrifice, had surrendered himself to the Germans to save Alina and those they sheltered. The wedding vows Alina had spoken in a refugee camp, a decision that altered her destiny, were not to Tomasz, but a desperate measure to ensure her survival and protect an even greater secret.
The layers of Alina's story peeled back to reveal a life marked by unimaginable loss, courage, and a love that transcended time. The secret she carried was a testament to the things one must do to endure, to the profound choices made when humanity hangs by a thread. For Alice, this journey was not only about her grandmother's past but a profound awakening to her own strength, to the power of her voice, and to the enduring legacy of love and resilience that flowed through her veins. The silence that had shrouded Alina's history finally broke, allowing truth, however painful, to bring a measure of peace and understanding to both women, spanning across generations and continents.
As the war tightened its relentless grip, Alina's world became one of constant anxiety. Tomasz, her steadfast hope, vanished, leaving behind only a gaping silence that echoed the growing despair. Where she once counted the days until his return, she now measured the spaces between hope and grief, all while navigating the watchful eyes of soldiers patrolling their farm. Survival became a daily struggle, a silent battle fought amidst the ruins of her innocence. Yet, amidst the terror, a desperate choice was made, a lie spoken that would bind her destiny and remain hidden for generations, a secret buried deep within her heart.
Decades later, in a world far removed from war-torn Poland, Alice found herself adrift in a different kind of battle. Her days were a relentless cycle of caring for her seven-year-old son, Eddie, who navigated the world through the lens of autism, and her bright, precocious daughter, Callie. Her marriage, too, felt stretched thin, her husband Wade often distant, absorbed by his career. Then came the call: her beloved Babcia, Alina, had suffered a stroke.
In the sterile quiet of the hospital room, Babcia, unable to speak, communicated through an iPad app, her urgent pleas directed at Alice. A journey to Poland, she insisted, to uncover a long-buried truth, to settle unfinished business that had haunted her for nearly eighty years. Reluctantly, Alice agreed, the weight of her grandmother's unspoken history pressing upon her. This unexpected quest, however, began to shift the dynamics at home, forcing Wade to step into the space Alice had always occupied, to connect with Eddie in ways he hadn't before.
Alice's pilgrimage to Poland unfolded like a detective story, each step bringing her closer to the heart of her grandmother's past. She retraced Alina's harrowing journey, the unimaginable atrocities endured during the Nazi occupation, and the profound sacrifices made for love and survival. She encountered the family of Tomasz's sister, Emilia, who were initially bewildered by Alice's claims, unsure how Alina could be Tomasz's granddaughter given his fate. Yet, the striking resemblance between Alice and the Polish family was undeniable, a living testament to a shared, hidden lineage.
Through Emilia's fragmented memories and Alice's own discoveries, the devastating truth began to emerge. Alina and Tomasz, deeply in love, had been caught in the brutal currents of war, their plans for escape intertwined with their efforts to protect a young Jewish couple and their infant daughter. Tomasz, in an act of extraordinary self-sacrifice, had surrendered himself to the Germans to save Alina and those they sheltered. The wedding vows Alina had spoken in a refugee camp, a decision that altered her destiny, were not to Tomasz, but a desperate measure to ensure her survival and protect an even greater secret.
The layers of Alina's story peeled back to reveal a life marked by unimaginable loss, courage, and a love that transcended time. The secret she carried was a testament to the things one must do to endure, to the profound choices made when humanity hangs by a thread. For Alice, this journey was not only about her grandmother's past but a profound awakening to her own strength, to the power of her voice, and to the enduring legacy of love and resilience that flowed through her veins. The silence that had shrouded Alina's history finally broke, allowing truth, however painful, to bring a measure of peace and understanding to both women, spanning across generations and continents.
What other readers say
Liked
Reviewers widely praise The Things We Cannot Say as a deeply emotional and impactful novel, often describing it as tear-jerking, heartwarming, and profoundly affecting. Many highlight the author's powerful and lyrical writing style, which creates a vivid and engaging narrative. The dual timeline structure, seamlessly weaving between past and present, is frequently lauded, with many readers finding both storylines equally compelling. The book is celebrated for its strong, unforgettable characters and its ability to introduce a fresh perspective on the World War II era in Poland. Key themes of love, loyalty, sacrifice, hope, and resilience resonate strongly with readers, alongside an authentic representation of family dynamics, including the challenges of raising a child with special needs. Overall, the storytelling is described as captivating and suspenseful, making it a highly memorable read for many.
Disliked
Despite its many strengths, some reviewers noted areas for improvement. A few found the narrative to be somewhat repetitive or over-explained, particularly regarding certain reveals, and suggested the book could have been shorter. While many loved the characters, some found Alice, the modern-day protagonist, to be occasionally unlikable, describing her as whiny, overly controlling, or judgmental, with her reliance on alcohol being a point of concern for one reader. Alina, the historical protagonist, was sometimes perceived as initially spoiled before her character developed significantly. Additionally, some felt the plot was predictable, or that the romance aspect, while central, became repetitive. One reviewer also questioned the historical accuracy regarding descriptions of Polish forests during WWII, and another found the pacing of the audiobook's dual narrators inconsistent, which impacted their engagement.
In short
In conclusion, The Things We Cannot Say is largely considered a powerful and unforgettable family saga that successfully interweaves themes of heartbreak, sacrifice, and enduring love across generations. It is highly recommended for readers who enjoy historical fiction, particularly those set during World War II, and appreciate emotional, character-driven narratives that explore resilience and the human spirit. The book will appeal to those who enjoy dual timeline stories, family dramas, and narratives that delve into the complexities of relationships and personal growth. Readers who appreciate authors known for evocative storytelling and who are prepared for an emotionally intense experience, often leading to tears, are likely to find this book a compelling and rewarding read.
No reviews yet. Be the first.





