Positives The Troll Inside You is widely praised for its accessibility, making it suitable for both casual readers and scholars interested in the subject. Reviewers highlight it as an excellent introduction to troll studies and a comprehensive overview of the supernatural elements found in Icelandic sagas. The book's structure, broken into many short, focused chapters, is frequently commended for enhancing readability and ensuring a smooth flow, making the exploration of complex ideas engaging. Many found it entertaining and insightful, particularly in its discussion of the troll as an uncanny, threatening presence representing humanity's fears and desire for self-protection.
Negatives However, some criticisms point to areas where the book could be improved. A few readers felt that the overall structure could have been more organized. Additionally, it is noted that a significant portion of the book draws from or re-elaborates on the author's previously published articles. Another common concern is that the writing can occasionally become bogged down in academic verbosity, potentially hindering the reading experience for some.
Conclusion Overall, The Troll Inside You is considered a valuable and insightful read that successfully covers the role of the supernatural within ancient sagas. Despite minor critiques regarding organization and style, it offers a compelling look at its subject matter. This book would particularly appeal to anyone with an interest in ancient sagas, folklore, and the broader concept of the supernatural, from those seeking a gentle introduction to more dedicated scholars.
