Then Again, Maybe I Won't

Reviewers consistently praise this book for its pioneering role in young adult literature, particularly for openly addressing the often-taboo subject of male puberty and adolescent anxieties. Many consider it a "boy's version" of the author's other classic, offering a much-needed guide for young readers navigating physical and emotional changes. The narrative is lauded for its realistic portrayal of a protagonist grappling with universal teenage problems, family dynamics, and the complexities of social class. Readers found the character's voice authentic and the story engaging, appreciating the author's ability to tackle significant life changes and social pressures with honesty and depth. It is often described as a well-written and important book that can spark valuable discussions.

However, the book receives notable criticism for certain elements that have not aged well. A significant concern revolves around the protagonist's actions involving a neighbor, which many reviewers found disturbing, creepy, and ethically problematic by modern standards. This aspect, in particular, led some to express discomfort and a reluctance to recommend it to younger readers today without significant contextual discussion. Some reviewers also found the main character to be unlikable or ungrateful at times, struggling to empathize with his reactions to his changing circumstances. Additionally, a few felt that certain plotlines were underdeveloped or left unresolved, and that the portrayal of some adult characters could be harsh. The direct and frank discussions of bodily changes, while praised by some, also made other readers feel uneasy or "cringeworthy."

Despite these reservations, the book is widely recognized as a significant work in young adult fiction, celebrated for its groundbreaking approach to adolescent issues. It is recommended for 'tween and early adolescent readers, especially boys, who are experiencing or curious about the physical and emotional changes of puberty, as well as the challenges of adapting to new social environments. However, many reviewers strongly advise that it be read with the guidance of a trusted adult to facilitate open discussions about its sensitive content and to address the aspects that may be viewed differently in contemporary society. Ultimately, it remains a classic for those interested in coming-of-age stories and the author's distinctive style, offering a snapshot of adolescent life from a particular historical context.