Positives Reviews for "Thistles and Thieves" generally highlight its strengths as a cozy mystery set in the picturesque Scottish Highlands. Many readers praise the engaging setting of Inversgail, with its charming descriptions and touches of Scottish culture, including Gaelic words. The book is often lauded for its focus on the strong friendships among the women who own the Yon Bonnie Books bookstore and tea room, describing their camaraderie as a core strength of the narrative. Readers found the characters warm, interesting, and believable, appreciating their repartee and their dynamic as the "S.C.O.N.E.S." The mystery itself is described by some as complex, well-plotted, and full of twists, providing an enjoyable and often surprising whodunit. The pacing is noted as a comfortable "cozy" speed, offering a delightful and lighthearted escape, with some finding it a stellar and solid addition to the series.
Negatives However, several readers express significant reservations, particularly regarding the book's pacing and character interactions. A common critique is the excessive amount of dialogue and speculation among the characters, often described as "talk, talk, talk" that leads to the plot "plodding along" rather than advancing with sufficient action. This constant theorizing and contradicting each other was found to be annoying and made it difficult to stay engaged for some. Additionally, some reviewers found the main characters, despite their strong friendships, to be at times grumpy, unlikeable, and even petty, displaying superior attitudes towards the local police and others. Specific character quirks or repetitive nicknames were also cited as becoming irritating. A few felt the mystery itself lacked compelling clues or that the central "box of books" plot element felt like a red herring, ultimately not enhancing the overall story.
Conclusion In conclusion, "Thistles and Thieves" is a book that will likely appeal most to dedicated fans of cozy mysteries, particularly those who prioritize character-driven narratives and a strong sense of place over fast-paced action. Readers who enjoy immersing themselves in a Scottish setting and appreciate a focus on female friendships, even with some quirky or occasionally frustrating character traits, will find much to like. Those who prefer mysteries with less dialogue and more direct investigative action, or who are easily put off by characters they perceive as condescending or overly verbose, might find this installment less satisfying.