Tidak ada negara Islam: Surat-surat politik Nurcholish Madjid-Mohamad Roem

The book is widely praised for its profound and coherent exploration of the concept of an Islamic state, presented through an engaging intellectual correspondence between two prominent figures, Nurcholish Madjid and Mohamad Roem. Reviewers highlight the clarity and depth with which the authors discuss the historical interpretations and contemporary relevance of this issue, particularly in the Indonesian context. Many found the book to be thought-provoking and mind-opening, offering progressive perspectives on Islam and its political dimensions. It is celebrated as a significant contribution to intellectual discourse, providing valuable insights into the role of Islamic intellectuals during the early days of the Indonesian republic and demonstrating remarkable foresight regarding future societal challenges. The inter-generational dialogue is consistently noted as a particular strength, making it a compelling read for those interested in nuanced discussions.

Despite its strong positive reception, the book is not without its criticisms. One reviewer found the content "uninteresting," a contrasting view to the general enthusiasm. Some readers also noted that certain parts of the discussion felt "unsettling" or "problematic" to them. Furthermore, the progressive ideas presented by the authors have historically faced condemnation and controversy from certain circles, which might present a challenge for readers who prefer less contentious topics or authors. A minor point of criticism was also directed at the physical presentation, with one reviewer finding the book's packaging unattractive.

Overall, this collection of correspondence is regarded as an essential and timely read, offering a comprehensive and insightful examination of Islamic political thought. It is highly recommended for readers seeking to deepen their understanding of how the concept of an Islamic state has been interpreted and debated, from Indonesia's pre-independence era to the present day. The book will particularly appeal to those interested in intellectual history, Islamic political movements, and the evolution of religious thought in a national context. It is best suited for open-minded individuals who appreciate detailed, coherent arguments and are willing to engage with potentially controversial yet well-articulated ideas that continue to resonate with contemporary issues.