Positives Readers widely agree that the second installment of the Amulet series marks a significant improvement over its predecessor, delivering an even more engaging and action-packed experience. The pacing is described as fast-moving and adventurous, keeping readers thoroughly immersed. A major highlight is the expanded and rich world-building, which reviewers found incredibly creative, intricate, and wonderful. Character development, particularly Emily's growth as a Stonekeeper and her internal struggles, is noted as believable and well-executed, with new characters making fantastic additions to the cast. Consistently, the artwork receives glowing praise for being amazing, gorgeous, vivid, and inventive, with many comparing its beauty to cinematic quality.
Negatives While largely positive, some minor criticisms were noted. A few readers felt that certain plot points or character archetypes, such as the protagonist's journey or the amulet's influence, felt somewhat reminiscent of classic fantasy tales. Additionally, some found the rapid pace, while exciting, left little room to ponder the more bizarre elements, leading to a slightly simplistic feel. One reviewer expressed a desire for more diverse female characters beyond the main protagonist and her mother. Another minor point mentioned was the occasional difficulty in recalling character names and a sense that the unique charm of the first book had slightly diminished for a few.
Conclusion Despite these minor points, the overwhelming consensus is that this book is a highly enjoyable and compelling read, often described as a clear win and an absolute gem. It comes highly recommended for all fantasy lovers, particularly those who appreciate "portal writing" narratives, anime or manga aesthetics, and the imaginative qualities of Miyazaki films. This volume is ideally suited for middle-grade readers, including young and reluctant readers, but its engaging story and stunning visuals ensure it also captivates adults. Readers who may have been lukewarm on the first book are especially encouraged to give this one a try, as many found it a vast improvement that deepens the series' appeal.
