Positives The book is widely praised for being packed with valuable information, offering a brilliant overview of herbalism history in the UK. Readers particularly appreciate the detailed sections outlining planetary characteristics from a medical perspective and their effects on the body. The connections between various herbs and their planetary links, along with their diverse medicinal and ritual uses, are highlighted as especially valuable. Additionally, the section on Decumbiture is noted for being clear and helpful for those interested in this astrological branch. The book is considered a great companion for those already familiar with the author’s previous work, providing insights into different herbs and their spiritual, magical, and medical applications, and helping to deepen understanding of herb constitution and actions in connection with astrology.
Negatives However, not all readers found the book equally compelling. One reviewer felt it personally fell short compared to the author's previous work, preferring the writing style and descriptions of "A Woman's Book of Herbs." The astrology aspect was occasionally perceived as complicated and difficult to understand. A notable criticism was the extensive use of paraphrasing and direct lifting of paragraphs from Culpeper's work. Some found this approach tedious, feeling as though they were reading parts of another book rather than the author's original content, questioning the necessity of such frequent attribution.
Conclusion Overall, despite some criticisms regarding the clarity of certain astrological concepts and the originality of historical references, the book is generally well-received for its comprehensive information and practical application. It is highly recommended for readers interested in deepening their understanding of herbal medicine, especially those who want to explore the intricate connections between herbs and astrology. This book serves as a valuable resource for both students and practitioners of herbalism, particularly those who appreciate historical context and the integration of medical astrology into their practice.
