Una inquietante simetría

Reviewers frequently praise Audrey Niffenegger's "Her Fearful Symmetry" for its beautiful, elegant, and imaginative writing style, which some found even stronger than her previous work. The novel’s setting in and around London's Highgate Cemetery is consistently highlighted as a major strength, creating a highly atmospheric and intriguing backdrop that acts almost as a character itself, rich with historical detail. Many readers found the book to be an engaging and unique read, offering innovative storytelling and an original premise that explores profound themes such as the intricate bonds between twins, isolation, love, death, and identity. The story is appreciated for its ability to prompt deep reflection, blending elements of a ghost story, romance, and even science fiction with suspenseful moments and thought-provoking turns. The depiction of a secondary character struggling with obsessive-compulsive disorder also received particular acclaim for its realistic and poignant portrayal.

Despite its strengths, the book proved divisive, with many reviewers expressing significant disappointment, particularly when comparing it to Niffenegger's highly successful debut, "The Time Traveler's Wife." A common criticism centers on the plot, which some found to be absurd, nonsensical, or to "go off the rails" in its latter half, with key narrative developments often perceived as predictable or clichéd. The pacing was frequently described as slow or aimless, leading some readers to struggle with engagement. Furthermore, many characters, including the central twin sisters, were often deemed unlikable, unsympathetic, ineffectual, or even "despicable," making it difficult for readers to form an emotional connection. Some critics also pointed out inconsistencies in character motivation and questioned the believability of how easily the characters accepted supernatural occurrences.

"Her Fearful Symmetry" emerges as a challenging and unconventional read that elicits strong, varied reactions. While it may not appeal to all, it is recommended for readers who appreciate deeply atmospheric ghost stories with a contemporary twist and a strong emphasis on complex psychological relationships. Those who enjoy Niffenegger's distinctive prose and are willing to suspend disbelief for a narrative that delves into unconventional themes of life, death, and identity will likely find it a rewarding experience. However, readers seeking a similar emotional journey or narrative structure to "The Time Traveler's Wife," or those who prefer straightforward plots and unequivocally likable characters, might find themselves disappointed by its unique direction and sometimes unsettling nature.