Une autobiographie

Reviewers widely praise the book for its deeply personal and honest portrayal of Neil Young, offering readers a unique insight into his mind and creative processes. Many found it to be a refreshing departure from traditional biographies, appreciating its intimate, conversational style that feels like listening to an old friend. The book is lauded for filling in details about Young's life beyond his music, touching on his passions for old cars, model trains, his family, and his various projects. Readers found his reflections on life, personal growth, and his experiences with sobriety to be particularly moving and relatable. Despite its unconventional structure, many fans found the narrative engaging and enjoyable, providing a genuine sense of connection with the artist.

Conversely, many readers found the book to be rambling, repetitive, and at times, incoherent. Critics frequently point out its lack of chronological order and the tendency to jump between topics without clear transitions, which can be frustrating for those expecting a linear autobiography. There is a common sentiment that the book dedicates too much space to Young's pet projects, such as his sound quality initiative and electric cars, sometimes feeling like an advertisement. Reviewers noted a surprising lack of detail about significant parts of his musical career, particularly his time with iconic bands, in favor of extensive discussions about his hobbies. Some found the writing style unedited and self-indulgent, leading to a dull or disappointing reading experience.

Ultimately, the book receives a mixed but generally positive reception, often described as flawed yet authentic, a true reflection of Neil Young's unique personality. While it may not be a conventionally great literary work, it is widely considered a must-read for dedicated fans who appreciate its raw, unpolished nature and the opportunity to delve into the artist's thoughts and obsessions. It is recommended for creatives, the curious, and anyone interested in understanding a passionate mind grappling with aging, creativity, and life's journey. However, readers seeking a traditional, chronological biography of Neil Young's career or those unfamiliar with his music might find it challenging and are advised to approach it with an open mind or start with his musical catalog first.