Ungifted

Gordon Korman

  • First published 1985
  • 316 pages
  • English
Donovan Curtis is a troublemaker, known more for his impulsive pranks than his academic achievements. When one of his grand schemes goes spectacularly wrong, he expects serious consequences. Instead, a bizarre administrative mix-up lands him in the Academy of Scholastic Distinction, a school exclusively for the nation's most brilliant and gifted students. Now, Donovan, an undeniably average kid, must navigate a world of child prodigies, advanced robotics, and intellectual pursuits he barely understands. As he tries to blend in and avoid being discovered as an imposter, he unexpectedly finds that his unique talents—which certainly aren't academic—might be exactly what the highly intelligent but socially awkward students of the ASD never knew they needed. This story explores what it truly means to be "gifted" and how different kinds of brilliance can come together to achieve extraordinary things.
4.05
28K ratings across the web
7 in 10 readers loved it, 1 didn't like it
The book "Ungifted" is widely praised for its engaging and humorous narrative. Readers frequently describe it as a fun, enjoyable, and compulsively readable story, often finishing it in one sitting. Many highlight the book's genuinely funny moments and competent, well-written prose. The characters, particularly the protagonist Donovan, are noted for being relatable, fun, and well-developed, with other figures also resonating positively with audiences. The use of alternating points of view is appreciated for keeping the story fresh and offering diverse perspectives. Beyond the humor, the book is recognized for making good points about how societal expectations and educational labeling can shape students' lives, and it thoughtfully questions the practice of completely separating talented students from the general student body. It is often described as sweet, sincere, and uplifting, offering valuable themes of friendship, teamwork, and fitting in. However, the reviews also point out significant criticisms, primarily concerning the book's premise and character portrayals. A major concern is the book's heavy reliance on stereotypes, particularly in its depiction of gifted students. Many reviewers find it ludicrous and implausible that all students at the Academy are presented as socially awkward, scientifically inclined, and lacking creativity, contrasting sharply with the "normal" and creative protagonist. Specific examples cited include a genius not knowing about popular online platforms and destructive behavior being lauded as a form of giftedness. This perpetuates what some consider to be unfair and untrue prejudices against highly intelligent individuals. Some critics also found the characters one-dimensional despite the multiple perspectives, and noted plot holes or unrealistic expectations of middle school life. For some, the narrative felt repetitive towards the end, and the "Donovan-worship" among the gifted students became tiresome. Despite these criticisms, many readers, especially its target audience, found "Ungifted" to be a charming and entertaining read. It is highly recommended for middle-grade readers, including those in elementary and middle school, who are likely to enjoy its humor, fast-paced plot, and relatable themes without being overly concerned with the accuracy of the stereotypes. The book offers an overarching message that anyone can achieve great things when given opportunities, regardless of their labeled intelligence, and it encourages discussions on character education and facing one's problems. While some adult readers might find the exaggerated elements and stereotypes problematic, younger audiences often embrace the story for its unique concept and engaging plot, making it a popular choice for a lighthearted and heartwarming experience.

No reviews yet. Be the first.