Ūslū 2: Salām bi-lā arḍ (Arabic Edition)

The book is widely lauded for providing crucial, albeit often painful, insights into the historical context and complexities surrounding the Oslo Accords. Readers appreciate its rigorous and well-substantiated critique, particularly from a perspective described as one of the least biased available. The author, Edward Said, is praised for his intellectual depth and for articulating a strong stance against perceived missteps in the peace process. The book emphasizes the importance of a deep understanding of all parties involved, advocating for a "liberation of the mind" from simplistic narratives and slogans. It is seen as an essential resource for comprehending the roots of current challenges and the motivations behind significant historical decisions, offering a detailed explanation of how the accords came to be and their immediate implications.

While the book's analysis is highly valued, some reviewers note that its focus on events from the mid-1990s means certain discussions might feel historically distant, suggesting the need for an updated perspective to fully grasp contemporary relevance. Additionally, some readers, while agreeing with the book's critique of the accords, express disagreement with certain political solutions or approaches advocated by Said within the text, particularly regarding concepts like a two-state solution and the role of negotiations. The book's portrayal of leadership figures and their decisions is described as unflinching and often harsh, which, while seen as honest by many, highlights the difficult and often controversial nature of the subject matter.

Overall, the book is considered a profoundly important and impactful work, with many reviewers affirming the enduring validity of Edward Said's criticisms in light of subsequent events. It serves as a powerful record of a major thinker's protest against what he perceived as a detrimental turning point. This book is highly recommended for readers interested in a deep, critical analysis of the Oslo Accords and their long-term consequences, as well as those seeking to understand the historical trajectory of the Israeli-Palestinian conflict from a perspective that challenges conventional narratives. It is particularly valuable for students of history, political science, and anyone seeking to learn from past decisions to inform a clearer understanding of present-day realities.