We Are Water Protectors (Caldecott Medal Winner)

Reviewers widely praise the book for its stunning and gorgeous illustrations, often described as luminous, dreamlike, and vibrant, with a notable use of blue tones and watercolor. The artwork, which earned the Caldecott Medal, is celebrated for its ability to convey a sense of tradition and contemporary relevance, making it a visual highlight. Beyond its aesthetic appeal, the book is lauded for its powerful, urgent, and inspiring message about the vital importance of water protection and environmental stewardship. Readers appreciate how it centers indigenous voices and traditions, weaving in cultural references and demonstrating the deep connection to land, water, and all living beings. The text is frequently described as poetic, lyrical, and accessible, empowering children to understand and engage with the concept of activism and standing up for what is right. Many found it to be a thought-provoking conversation starter on environmentalism, indigenous cultures, and social justice.

Despite widespread acclaim, some reviewers expressed a desire for more concrete, actionable steps that children could take to become "water protectors" in their daily lives. While the book provides an inspiring call to action and a pledge, a common criticism was that it lacked practical "how-to" strategies beyond joining protests, which might not be accessible or clear for young readers. Some felt that the nuances of the environmental and tribal rights issues might go over the heads of the target child audience. Additionally, the depiction of the oil pipeline as a "black snake," while effective as a metaphor, was noted by a few as potentially frightening for very sensitive youngsters or as a negative portrayal of snakes, though this was often balanced by acknowledging its likely roots in indigenous tradition. There was also a sentiment that the story, while powerful, felt more like a set of principles or aphorisms rather than a traditional narrative plot.

Overall, the book is highly recommended as a beautiful and important work that effectively highlights environmental justice and the significance of protecting natural resources, particularly water. Its strength lies in its ability to introduce complex themes of activism and indigenous wisdom in an engaging and visually captivating manner. This book would resonate deeply with readers of all ages, from young children to adults, who are interested in environmentalism, indigenous cultures, and social justice. It is particularly valuable for families and educators seeking to spark conversations about stewardship, community action, and the interconnectedness of life, even if supplemental resources might be desired for practical application. It is seen as a crucial addition to libraries and bookshelves for its timely message and stunning artistry.