Positives The reviews highlight this book as an informative and eye-opening introduction to the world of non-verbal communication. Many readers found it a valuable resource for deciphering body language, appreciating the author's extensive experience as an ex-FBI agent, which lends credibility to the insights provided. The book is praised for its accessible and straightforward writing style, making complex concepts easy to understand for a general audience. A significant strength noted by reviewers is the author's emphasis on interpreting body language in terms of comfort and discomfort, rather than offering simplistic rules for lie detection. This nuanced approach, coupled with the detailed breakdown of various body cues, is seen as a refreshing and practical guide for improving interpersonal communication. Some also recommend it specifically for authors seeking to enrich character descriptions.
Negatives Despite its positive aspects, several reviewers found the book to be quite basic, with much of the information presented as obvious or intuitive, especially for those already familiar with body language concepts. Critics frequently describe the writing as didactic, repetitive, and lacking "spark," making it a somewhat dry or boring read akin to a textbook. Some expressed disappointment that the book did not delve into more complex or surprising observations, often relying on the author's personal anecdotes rather than robust scientific proof or FBI-specific examples. The accompanying illustrations were sometimes deemed cartoonish or unnecessary, and certain sections, such as advice on dressing, were considered irrelevant filler. A few readers also noted that the book's focus on interrogation-style observation did not cater to those seeking guidance on everyday social interactions or controlling one's own non-verbal signals.
Conclusion Overall, "What Every Body Is Saying" is considered a solid, if sometimes elementary, primer for understanding non-verbal cues. While it may not offer groundbreaking revelations for seasoned students of body language, it serves as a competent and balanced introduction for beginners. Readers new to the subject, those wishing to improve their general observational skills, or individuals interested in the author's unique perspective on human behavior will likely find value here. However, it requires a commitment to practice and study to effectively apply its lessons in real-life situations. Those seeking advanced psychological theory, definitive lie-detection methods, or specific advice for navigating personal relationships might find the scope somewhat limited.
