What If?

Shari Low

  • First published 1998
  • 562 pages
  • English
In 1999, Carly Cooper, at 30 and still single, faces a nagging question: did she let "Mr. Right" slip away after nearly saying "I do" to six different men? Convinced her true love is among her past relationships, Carly makes a drastic decision, abandoning her job and flat to embark on a global quest. This journey takes her across continents, revisiting ex-boyfriends in an era before the ease of internet searches and smartphones, making her mission a genuine challenge. As Carly reconnects with the men from her past, she grapples with the lingering "what ifs" and the possibility that they may have moved on. This humorous and heartfelt rom-com explores the complexities of love, friendship, and self-discovery as Carly navigates her past to secure her future.
4.16
11K ratings across the web
8 in 10 readers loved it
Reviewers largely praise the book as a smart, humorous, and uplifting romantic comedy, frequently noting how much they laughed and enjoyed the quality time spent reading. Many highlighted the entertaining and unique plot, which involves the protagonist revisiting past relationships to learn from mistakes and shape her future happiness. The author's witty and agile writing style is consistently commended, with readers finding the narrative engaging, heartfelt, and often fast-paced. The book's setting in the late 1990s also resonated positively, evoking a strong sense of nostalgia for a simpler era before widespread social media and smartphones, with chapter titles themed by popular songs from the period adding to the charm. The strong portrayal of friendship and the protagonist's journey of self-discovery were also frequently mentioned as significant strengths. However, some readers expressed reservations, primarily concerning the main character, Carly. A segment of reviewers found her to be self-centered, fickle, and at times unlikable, criticizing her tendency to jump into and out of relationships without clear explanation or consideration for others. For some, her romantic escapades felt unrealistic or exaggerated, while others found the plot repetitive in its structure. There were also comments that the humor occasionally missed the mark or that the story felt slow to start. A few reviewers felt the ending was rushed, clichéd, or predictable, leading to a less satisfying conclusion for them. Overall, the book is generally regarded as a fun, lighthearted, and entertaining read, particularly for fans of witty women's fiction and romantic comedies. It is highly recommended for those seeking an uplifting escape, especially readers who appreciate a nostalgic trip to the 1990s and enjoy stories centered on strong friendships, personal growth, and the quest for love. While some may find the protagonist's actions challenging or the plot somewhat predictable, many reviewers found it to be a delightful and engaging story that warms the heart and stands the test of time.

No reviews yet. Be the first.