Positives Many reviewers found this collection of poetry to be sweet, wholesome, and utterly charming. Readers praised its light and easy nature, with many poems described as funny, cute, and full of delightful rhythm and fun rhymes. The book is celebrated for its ability to transport readers back to a whimsical, imaginative childhood world, often centered around Christopher Robin's early experiences. The illustrations by Ernest H. Shepard are consistently lauded as lovely and perfectly fitting for the poems, enhancing the overall appeal. Reviewers found the verses simple yet scintillating, offering a pure voice of innocent wonder that can be a delight to read aloud and share across generations, and it even introduces an early version of a famous bear character.
Negatives However, some readers expressed significant disappointment, particularly those expecting more direct connections to the well-known Winnie-the-Pooh narratives and characters. Several found the poems too simple, at times clunky, and alarmingly outdated, suggesting that modern children, accustomed to faster-paced entertainment, might not appreciate the book as much as past generations. Reviewers noted that many poems do not feature Pooh or his friends prominently, focusing instead on other childhood experiences that can feel strange or foreign due to dated references. For some, the content felt average, lacking the "magic of the Hundred Acre Wood" they craved, and the repetitive nature of some longer poems was not always enjoyed.
Conclusion Ultimately, When We Were Very Young elicits a mixed but generally appreciative response. While it may not appeal to all contemporary young readers seeking fast-paced narratives or explicit Winnie-the-Pooh adventures, it remains a beloved collection for those who appreciate classic children's poetry and the charm of a bygone era. It is highly recommended for adults seeking a nostalgic journey back to their own childhood or for parents and grandparents who wish to share a gentle, imaginative world with children, understanding that some cultural references may require explanation. The book is particularly suited for readers who value the pure joy of language, rhythm, and the innocent wonder of early childhood, regardless of its age.
