Positives Reviewers found many aspects of the book engaging, often praising its fast-paced, action-packed narrative that kept them enthralled. Many appreciated the expanded world-building, which offered new insights into the dystopian setting and its intricate societal structures. The author's writing style was frequently described as easy, quick, and captivating, with vivid descriptions that drew readers into the story. Some readers also commended the constant transformations of the main character, Tally, through different societal roles, finding her evolving perspectives on the city and its inhabitants to be a unique and interesting approach. The audiobook narration was also highlighted as a strong point, enhancing the listening experience.
Negatives Despite its strengths, the book garnered significant criticism, particularly regarding character development. Many reviewers expressed frustration with the protagonist, Tally, finding her personality shifts due to repeated alterations to be repetitive rather than leading to meaningful growth, with some describing her as unlikeable or stagnant. The plot itself was often deemed unsatisfactory, unoriginal, and hastily put together, leaving too many unresolved questions and feeling anti-climactic for a series finale. A major point of contention was the inclusion of self-harm, depicted as a means for characters to maintain mental clarity, which many found irresponsible and inappropriate for a young adult audience without a critical discussion of its harmfulness. Other concerns included a perceived lack of moral compass among characters, thinly explored societal concepts, and relationships that felt superficial or forced.
Conclusion Ultimately, the book receives a highly mixed reception, with readers often having ambivalent feelings about it as the conclusion to the series. While it offers a fast-paced and adventurous journey through a compelling dystopian world, its narrative and character choices proved divisive. This book might appeal to readers who enjoy futuristic young adult sci-fi with a focus on societal control and rebellion, and who appreciate a protagonist that undergoes drastic changes. However, those seeking a traditional, fully resolved epic finale, consistent character growth, or a clear moral message might find themselves disappointed by its unconventional approach and the contentious themes explored within.