Positives The book is highly praised for its engrossing portrayal of espionage during wartime, focusing on intricate "smoke and mirror" operations. Readers found it a fascinating and detailed exploration of intelligence dynamics, character quirks, and the complex, ever-evolving "chess game" played by intelligence communities. The narrative excels in detailing both successful and unsuccessful operations, along with vivid descriptions of the eccentric individuals involved. The interconnected nature of the stories, with agents reappearing across different accounts, helps build a comprehensive understanding of how events unfolded and coincided. It highlights a monumental deception campaign, involving a unique group that spun an elaborate web of fabrications, demonstrating the profound influence these operations had on key historical events. The true-to-life nature of these accounts, featuring real people, their triumphs, tragedies, and heartbreaks, adds significant depth and impact.
Negatives While the extensive detail is a strength, it is also identified as the book's primary drawback. Reviewers noted that the sheer volume of information can make it a "really long read," occasionally hindering the pace and making it challenging to progress through the narrative. This density of detail, while appreciated for its thoroughness, can sometimes make the book feel arduous to get through.
Conclusion Overall, the book is considered an absolutely brilliant and great omnibus, delivering compelling non-fiction accounts of wartime intelligence. Despite its length and dense detail, the rich content and fascinating subject matter make it a highly rewarding read for those interested in espionage, military history, and the human element behind grand strategic deceptions. It is particularly recommended for readers who appreciate meticulous historical detail, complex character studies, and the intricacies of intelligence operations during significant global conflicts.
