‏تارىخ شفاهى دفاع مقدس :‏ ‏مجموعه مقاله هاى هماىش ملى تارىخ شفاهى با محورىت دفاع مقدس

One review highlighted a particular article, "Opportunities in memoir writing and oral history of the Islamic Revolution," as being good. This specific contribution was noted for its quality within the collection, standing out among the other pieces.

However, the overall sentiment regarding the majority of the book's content was largely critical. Many articles were described as loose, incoherent, and lacking in substantial content, often relying on impressive titles and extensive references rather than depth. One reviewer found most contributions to be of poor quality, ranging from "insulting" to only offering a few interesting points across lengthy pieces. This suggests a general lack of insightful or engaging material throughout much of the collection.

In conclusion, the book appears to be a collection of articles with highly inconsistent quality. While one piece stands out positively, the overwhelming majority received criticism for their lack of substance and poor execution. This book might appeal to very specific readers, such as researchers or academics deeply embedded in the niche fields of oral history, memoir writing, or the historical context of the Islamic Revolution, who are prepared to critically evaluate the material and sift through varying quality for specific insights. It is likely less suitable for a general audience seeking consistently high-quality or easily digestible content.