دارىوش بزرگ

The reviews generally praise the book, with one reader describing it as a very valuable work. Another reviewer found it to be a good book overall, despite the strong historical and emotional reflections it provoked. The book is appreciated for its general quality and the engagement it fosters with its subject matter.

The primary criticism leveled against the book concerns its historical sourcing. One reviewer points out that the author extensively relies on Zabihollah Mansouri's "Sar-zamin-e Javid" as a main source. This is problematic because Mansouri's works are widely considered secondary historical accounts rather than first-rate academic sources, potentially affecting the book's scholarly rigor and accuracy.

Overall, the book appears to be well-received for its general quality and value, though its historical methodology is questioned by some. It would likely appeal to readers interested in the historical period it covers, particularly those who appreciate a narrative approach to history. However, readers seeking strictly academic or primary-source-based historical analysis might approach it with caution due to the noted issues with its sourcing.