كويتية في غوانتاناموا

The reviews for "Kuwaiti in Guantanamo" highlight the author's remarkable courage and pioneering spirit. Many readers praised the writer's engaging and accessible style, particularly in the initial chapters, which made the book an enjoyable and quick read. Reviewers appreciated her ability to convey the strict security measures and the general atmosphere of mystery surrounding the facility, without taking a biased stance. The book is seen by some as a valuable documentation of a unique personal experience, offering basic information about Guantanamo and prompting reflection on human rights contradictions. The author's role as the first Arab, and specifically Kuwaiti, female journalist to visit such a sensitive location was a significant positive point.

However, a recurring criticism among reviewers was the book's lack of depth and detailed content. Many felt it read more like a collection of journalistic reports or a travel diary rather than a cohesive narrative, failing to deliver the profound insights expected from its intriguing title. A major disappointment was the absence of in-depth information about the detainees' lives, their treatment, or the prison's inner workings, as the author's access was largely limited to the periphery and official accounts. Reviewers also noted an excessive focus on the author's personal journey and achievements, including self-praise, which detracted from the main subject. The book was further criticized for its delayed publication, a perceived missed opportunity to contribute to a timely discussion, and for a sometimes disorganized structure and a lack of emotional resonance.

In conclusion, "Kuwaiti in Guantanamo" offers a mixed reading experience. While lauded for the author's bravery, her groundbreaking role, and a clear, engaging writing style, it often falls short for those expecting a comprehensive or emotionally impactful account of the detention center. This book would primarily appeal to readers interested in a straightforward, personal narrative of a unique journalistic endeavor, or those keen on understanding the author's journey and her role in challenging cultural norms. However, readers seeking deep investigative insights into the lives of detainees, extensive details about the prison's operations, or a profound literary exploration of its complexities may find the book lacking in substance and narrative depth.