چون بوي تلخ خوش كندر زندگی‌نامه‌ی فرهاد مهراد

Below is a balanced summary of the reviews for the book "Because of the Bitter Sweet Scent of Frankincense."

The book is widely praised for offering a multi-dimensional and intimate portrait of Farhad Mehrad, an iconic artist. Many readers, especially those who admire his music, found the book deeply engaging and a valuable resource for understanding the man behind the voice. Reviewers consistently highlight the book's balanced approach, presenting Farhad as a complex human being with unique traits, avoiding both idealization and harsh criticism. His intellectual depth, extensive reading habits, patriotism, and unwavering commitment to his ideals, particularly during challenging periods, are frequently mentioned as compelling aspects revealed in the narrative. The inclusion of Farhad's personal notes, letters, handwriting, and numerous photographs – some in color – is a significant draw, providing a tangible connection to his life and thought processes. The writing style is often described as fluent and accessible, making it an enjoyable read that sheds light on the creation and context of his beloved songs.

However, the book also received criticism, particularly from long-time fans who felt it lacked new information, echoing content already available in documentaries or other existing biographies. Some reviewers found the narrative structure to be somewhat disorganized, scattered, or feeling like a collection of notes rather than a cohesive biographical work. Concerns were raised about a perceived bias in the author's portrayal, with some feeling there was an "unsubtle exaggeration" of Farhad's positive attributes or an overly pious depiction, which detracted from an objective account. Critics also noted that while the book touches upon various aspects of his personal life, it occasionally lacks depth, failing to fully explore certain issues or answer deeper questions about his beliefs or personal struggles. The prominent role of Farhad's wife's perspective was also mentioned as potentially leading to an incomplete or skewed narrative, leaving some gaps in the overall picture.

Despite these criticisms, "Because of the Bitter Sweet Scent of Frankincense" is generally considered a worthwhile and engaging read. It successfully humanizes Farhad Mehrad, presenting him as a profoundly unique and influential figure beyond his musical achievements. This book is particularly recommended for casual fans, new admirers, or anyone seeking to understand the personality and intellectual world of Farhad. Readers who appreciate biographies that offer a balanced view of a complex individual, enriched with personal insights and visual documentation, will likely find this a deeply satisfying experience, even if it doesn't uncover every hidden facet of his life.