The reviewer, an international student who utilized this textbook at Waseda University, indicated that aside from a couple of specific points of concern, they encountered no other significant issues with the material. This suggests that the textbook maintains a general level of functionality and acceptability, providing a foundational learning experience in most areas not explicitly criticized. It implies that the core content, structure, and exercises were largely adequate, apart from the noted shortcomings.
Disliked
However, the review points out two key areas where the textbook falls short. Firstly, the student felt that the explanations or guidance regarding "connections" – possibly referring to how various grammatical points link together or how to construct cohesive sentences and discourse – were frequently insufficient. Secondly, for individuals attempting to study Japanese independently rather than within a formal classroom environment, there was a perceived scarcity of adequate example sentences, which could impede self-directed learning and practical application.
In short
In conclusion, this textbook appears to be a functional resource, especially when its use is integrated into a structured classroom setting, given the absence of other major problems. Nevertheless, its effectiveness is reduced for those pursuing independent study due to a lack of comprehensive example sentences and potentially unclear guidance on linguistic connections. Therefore, this book would likely be most beneficial for students who are part of a university course where instructors can supplement the material with further explanations and examples, rather than for individuals primarily engaged in self-study.