云中命案

Reviewers widely praise this novel for its ingenious premise, setting a classic locked-room mystery within the confines of an airplane high above the clouds. Many found the plot to be excellent, gripping, and addictive, filled with numerous red herrings and twists that kept them guessing until the very end. Hercule Poirot is highlighted as being at his best, showcasing his superior "little grey cells," charming demeanor, and a more confident, playful sense of humor. The cast of characters is generally well-regarded, with Christie's skill in creating plausible and distinct personalities noted. The writing style is appreciated for its descriptive quality, conciseness, and ability to maintain interest throughout. For those who listened to the audiobook, the narration was also a significant highlight, enhancing the overall experience.

Despite its strengths, several reviewers found the book to be among Agatha Christie's less exceptional works, not quite reaching the heights of her most famous novels. A significant and frequently cited drawback for modern readers is the presence of casual racism and other prejudices expressed by some characters, which many found jarring and detestable, detracting from their immersion in the story. Some also raised concerns about the plausibility of certain plot elements or the murder method, finding aspects of the mystery to be overly complex or far-fetched. A few readers felt that certain patterns in Christie's writing were becoming repetitive, occasionally allowing them to anticipate the killer's identity, while others expressed indifference or dissatisfaction with the final reveal.

Overall, this installment is considered a solid and entertaining read that successfully delivers a classic Hercule Poirot mystery. While it may not be universally ranked as Christie's absolute masterpiece, it excels in its clever construction and ability to intrigue and surprise. It is highly recommended for fans of the Hercule Poirot series and those who enjoy closed-set mysteries with a diverse range of suspects. Readers who appreciate intricate plots and the challenge of solving a complex puzzle will likely find it gratifying. However, potential readers should be aware of the dated social attitudes present in the text and be prepared to engage with the book as a product of its time.