Positives This graphic novel is widely praised for its exceptional artistic quality and unique atmosphere. Readers consistently highlight the stunning black and white illustrations by Jaromír99, which are described as perfect, highly contrasted, and instrumental in creating a dark, melancholic, and sometimes dreamlike mood. The narrative concept is considered original and engaging, blending reality with elements of dreams and hallucinations. Many appreciate the raw, human, and often poignant depiction of loneliness and the lives of various characters connected by the evocative setting of trains and railway stations, a recurring motif that resonates with enthusiasts of the theme. The well-crafted text and language also contribute to the rich, immersive experience, with some reviewers finding it a "delicacy" for its noir and dramatic qualities.
Negatives However, a significant number of readers found the story challenging to follow due to its chaotic and non-linear narrative. Complaints frequently mention the confusing chronology, the jumps between episodes, and difficulty understanding the connections between characters or the overall plot progression. For some, this fragmentation made the reading experience tiresome or even boring, leaving them with a sense that the story merely "skims the surface" despite its raw depiction of an era. There were also comments about a lack of strong character development and the occasional struggle to differentiate between male characters, further contributing to the perceived disorientation.
Conclusion Overall, this graphic novel appears to be a polarizing work, celebrated for its artistic merit and distinctive mood but often criticized for its complex and disjointed storytelling. It is recommended for readers who appreciate visually striking graphic novels with a dark, melancholic, and noir atmosphere, and who are open to a fragmented narrative that blurs the lines between reality and dreams. It will particularly appeal to those interested in the historical and social context of the Central European railway environment and who do not require a straightforward, easily digestible plot, preferring instead to engage with a more abstract and emotionally evocative experience.
