Having witnessed Ayesha's dramatic demise, Horace Holly and Leo Vincey are haunted by her presence and her promise of return, sixteen years later. Driven by a vision, they embark on a perilous journey through uncharted lands, battling murderous tribes, avalanches, and glaciers. Their quest leads them to the enigmatic court of Kaloon, ruled by the formidable Khan Rassen and his imperious wife, the Khania Atene.
As danger mounts in this uneasy realm, Leo believes he has finally located Ayesha, yet she is almost unrecognizable. The love between Ayesha and Leo, an epic connection spanning centuries, faces new challenges as Eastern beliefs in reincarnation play a significant role in their reunion. This gothic-fantasy adventure offers a tale of passion, revenge, and the enduring power of a love that transcends time and death.
The journey begins years after the devastating events in Kôr, where the immortal Ayesha, "She-Who-Must-Be-Obeyed," seemingly perished in the Pillar of Fire. Horace Holly and Leo Vincey, forever altered by their encounter with her, find themselves haunted by Ayesha's last, cryptic words, which promised her return. A vision guides Leo, who remains utterly consumed by his love for Ayesha, believing her to be the reincarnation of his ancient beloved, Kallikrates. He is driven by an unshakeable conviction that she lives, somewhere in the vast, untamed reaches of Asia, and he compels Holly to join him in this desperate, mystical quest.
Their arduous search leads them through desolate landscapes and across towering mountains, far from the known world. They encounter strange peoples and ancient cultures, each step drawing them deeper into a realm where myth and reality blur. The companions are guided by fragmented clues and an almost supernatural intuition, pushing forward despite the immense dangers and the passage of years. Leo's unwavering faith in Ayesha's continued existence fuels their resolve, even as Holly, ever the pragmatist, grapples with the unlikelihood of their mission.
Eventually, their quest brings them to the hidden kingdom of Kaloon, a land nestled amidst towering peaks, ruled by the fierce Khan and his enchanting wife, Atene. Atene, a woman of striking beauty and formidable will, is immediately captivated by Leo. She sees in him the fulfillment of her own ancient prophecies and desires, believing him to be the reincarnation of her lost love, Amenartas. Her obsession with Leo mirrors, in a strange echo, Ayesha's own profound attachment, creating a perilous entanglement for the weary travelers.
The atmosphere in Kaloon is thick with intrigue and ancient rivalries. The Khan, a figure of madness and jealousy, rules with an iron fist, his court a web of suspicion and dark magic. Simbri, an evil shaman and magician, wields considerable influence, his presence casting a shadow over the land. Holly and Leo soon find themselves caught in the dangerous machinations of this foreign court, where their very lives are at stake. Atene's love for Leo intensifies, threatening to ignite the Khan's wrath and plunge them into a deadly conflict.
It is within this perilous setting that the true nature of their quest begins to reveal itself. Hints of Ayesha's presence emerge, subtle at first, then growing more undeniable. The companions learn of the House of Fire, an ancient cult of Isia worshippers, and their high priestess, a figure of immense power and mystery. As they navigate the political dangers of Kaloon, the magnetic pull of Ayesha grows stronger, drawing them towards the heart of the enigma.
Finally, they come face to face with the High Priestess of the House of Fire, who is, unmistakably, Ayesha herself. She has returned, having been reborn in a new form, her immortal spirit once again inhabiting a mortal body. Yet, this rebirth has brought with it a temporary loss of her memories and powers, making her vulnerable and human. The reunion is fraught with complex emotions; Leo is overjoyed, while Holly observes with a mixture of awe and trepidation, recalling Ayesha's ambiguous nature, her capacity for both profound love and terrible cruelty.
Ayesha's return reignites the themes of reincarnation and immortal love, but also brings forth the enduring question of good and evil, and the price of aspiring to divine knowledge. Her character, both noble and awe-inspiring, yet capable of unsettling actions, continues to challenge conventional morality. The story culminates in a dramatic confrontation, as Ayesha regains her full powers and memories, leading to a profound reckoning with her past and her future, and ultimately concluding the incredible and thrilling drama of mystery, reincarnation, and immortal love.
What other readers say
Liked
Reviewers largely praise the book as a worthy and enjoyable continuation of the classic "She." Many found the character of Ayesha, "She-Who-Must-Be-Obeyed," to be beautifully portrayed, an epitome of female power, knowledge, and captivating beauty that resonates long after reading. The narrative is often described as thrilling and adventurous, featuring exciting scenes and a suspenseful plot from beginning to end. Readers appreciate the author's imaginative writing, superb descriptions, and evocative prose, which maintains a timeless quality despite its age. The Asian setting, particularly the Himalayas and Tibet, is noted for its interesting world-building, and the book is recognized for its significant influence on the development of the fantasy and science fiction genres. Some also highlight the engaging journey of the main characters and the exploration of themes like love, sacrifice, and fate.
Disliked
Despite its strengths, many reviewers found "The Return of She" to be less groundbreaking or as enthralling as its predecessor, "She." Common criticisms include a slower pace, particularly in the middle sections, with some feeling the narrative could be condensed. A few readers expressed disappointment with unexplained plot points or a perceived lack of resolution for central mysteries. There are observations that Ayesha herself seems less powerful or smaller in scope compared to the original, and some character motivations are questioned. The dialogue and writing style are occasionally described as overly verbose, stilted, or cliched, contributing to a sense that the plot can at times be nonsensical or rely on over-the-top mystical elements. Some also felt the story was somewhat repetitive, echoing elements from the first book.
In short
Overall, "The Return of She" is considered a fine adventure that, while not always matching the original's impact, successfully continues the beloved saga. It offers a rich blend of adventure, mystery, and romance, deeply rooted in the author's distinctive style. This book is highly recommended for admirers and fans of the original "She" who are eager to follow the ongoing quest of its iconic characters and delve deeper into its unique blend of fantasy and philosophy. It will also appeal to readers who enjoy classic adventure novels with mystical elements, particularly those who appreciate the historical context of Victorian literature and its influence on speculative fiction.