Bonhoeffer on Resistance: The Word Against the Wheel

Reviewers widely praise this book for offering a clear, timely, and enlightening exploration of Dietrich Bonhoeffer's writings on resistance to injustice, particularly concerning the role of churches and individuals. It is seen as an invaluable resource for readers already familiar with Bonhoeffer's other works who wish to delve deeper into his concept of resistance. The author, a recognized scholar, is commended for presenting a coherent and systematic account, drawing connections between well-known and more obscure texts to reveal the continuities in Bonhoeffer's thought, often rooted in Lutheran theological traditions. The book successfully clarifies common misconceptions about Bonhoeffer's motivations, emphasizing his gospel- and church-centered approach to resistance and its theological underpinnings, making it a persuasive and nuanced reading of his work. Its analysis is considered particularly relevant for contemporary discussions on Church and State conflicts and ethical resistance.

Despite its strengths, some reviewers noted that the book might not appeal to all readers. It is described as academic in nature, potentially challenging for those without a background in Lutheran theology or Bonhoeffer studies, leading to some difficulty in fully grasping its arguments. While praised for its systematic approach, this method was felt by some to sideline aspects of Bonhoeffer's later, more personal writings, which were seen as less integrated into the core argument. Additionally, the detailed presentation of various types of resistance could have benefited from clearer organizational outlines, as some readers found it hard to recall all the distinctions by the end of the book. It is also acknowledged that the book is not designed to be a devotional classic.

Overall, this book is highly recommended as an essential companion for those seeking a profound and theologically grounded understanding of Bonhoeffer's approach to resistance, especially in times of moral challenge. It serves as an excellent starting point for anyone interested in Bonhoeffer studies, providing critical insights into his theology and thought beyond popular assumptions. While it may require a dedicated reading, particularly for those new to the subject matter, it offers a crucial caution against anachronistic applications of Bonhoeffer's ideas to modern political discourse. This makes it particularly valuable for church leaders, scholars, and anyone who desires a nuanced and deeply informed perspective on Bonhoeffer's legacy concerning ethical and political resistance.