Positives Many reviewers praise "Dear Evan Hansen" as a deeply moving and thought-provoking experience, even when encountered through the script rather than the live musical. Readers found the story captivating, stunning, and often hilarious, while also being profoundly heartbreaking. The narrative is lauded for its raw honesty in tackling heavy topics such as mental illness, anxiety, and the complexities of grief and connection in modern society. Many felt a deep personal connection to the characters and their struggles, particularly those dealing with feelings of invisibility, loneliness, and social awkwardness. The script is frequently described as impactful, creating a strong emotional response that often led to tears, making readers "feel" on a profound level. For those familiar with the musical's soundtrack, reading the script while listening to the music was consistently highlighted as an immersive and powerful alternative to seeing the live performance, enhancing understanding and emotional resonance.
Negatives Despite widespread acclaim, some reviewers expressed reservations about the book. A common point of criticism is that reading the script, while valuable, cannot fully replicate the transformative experience of seeing the live musical, especially missing the acclaimed performances of the original cast. A significant number of negative comments focused on the central character and a foundational deception within the story. Some readers found the character's actions to be morally questionable and felt that personal struggles did not fully justify the emotional distress caused to others. These readers were often left feeling "pissed off" or unsatisfied by the perceived lack of clear consequences for the character's choices, finding the ending to be a letdown for this reason. Additionally, a few reviewers found the story itself to be somewhat basic or overhyped, or noted a personal dislike for narratives centered around lying characters. Some also felt the script, on its own, limited the emotional depth compared to a novel, requiring the reader to actively fill in those feelings.
Conclusion Overall, "Dear Evan Hansen" is largely considered a powerful and emotionally charged narrative that resonates deeply with many readers. While the script offers a profound experience, it is widely recommended that readers listen to the acclaimed soundtrack concurrently to maximize its impact, serving as the closest alternative to witnessing the live Broadway production. This book is particularly recommended for teenagers and parents, as well as anyone who has experienced feelings of isolation, anxiety, or a struggle to connect. It appeals to those seeking a story that honestly explores themes of mental health, truth, and the desire to belong. Be prepared for an intense emotional journey, as the story is designed to provoke strong feelings and encourage reflection on complex human experiences.
