Death Note, Vol. 5

Readers found elements of this volume to be quite strong, with some calling the series a "timeless work of art" and another "fabulous as always." The initial segment of the book, focusing on the main character's changed circumstances and confinement, was particularly well-received. Despite a shift in direction, many appreciated the continued intrigue and build-up for future developments, with some expressing excitement for the next installment. The introduction of new supporting characters, such as a con artist and a burglar, was seen as a nice addition to the cast. Furthermore, the new mystery surrounding a "third Kira" and the challenge for readers to deduce their identity alongside the detective character added a layer of suspense. Some also enjoyed the portrayal of the main character as a compassionate individual once freed from certain influences.

Conversely, a significant number of reviewers felt this volume marked a decline in quality compared to previous entries. The most common critique centered on the story's shift away from the compelling intellectual battles between the two main protagonists, with many missing their "mind games" and "witty banter." The new plotline involving corrupt businessmen and a finance company was widely considered less engaging and appealing than the original premise, with some finding it tedious and overly complicated. Several readers expressed a lack of interest in these new corporate characters and felt the story "lost steam." The absence of a popular supernatural character was also noted as a disappointment. Other criticisms included perceived plot inconsistencies, such as a character's health issues or the differing treatment of detained individuals, and some found certain character interactions or resolutions to be unrealistic or handled too hastily.

Overall, this volume elicits a mixed response, generally considered to be a weaker entry in the series but still holding enough appeal for many to continue reading. While it may not deliver the intense, cat-and-mouse dynamic that defined earlier volumes, it attempts to inject fresh air into the plot by introducing new characters and a different kind of mystery. This book would likely appeal to established fans of the series who are invested in the overarching narrative and open to significant changes in pacing and focus. Readers who appreciate character development, new mysteries, and a slower build-up to future events, even if it means a temporary departure from the core conflict, may still find enjoyment in this installment. However, those primarily drawn to the original premise of a direct, high-stakes rivalry might find it less satisfying.