Positives The book is widely lauded for its exceptionally beautiful and poetic writing style, which many reviewers found enchanting and deeply moving. Readers were captivated by the lyrical prose, describing it as exquisite and soul-touching. The central romance between Iris and Roman is a significant highlight, praised as tender, emotionally raw, and incredibly swoon-worthy. Reviewers adored the "rivals to lovers" dynamic, particularly the "he falls first" trope, and found their connection through letters to be the most intimate and honest aspect of the story. Both protagonists are highly celebrated; Iris is admired for her strength, bravery, and relatability, while Roman is hailed as a selfless, charming, and devoted love interest. The narrative is noted for its captivating plot and its ability to beautifully explore heavy themes such as war, grief, and loss, while ultimately focusing on hope and human connection.
Negatives Despite strong praise, some reviewers expressed reservations, primarily concerning the fantasy and world-building elements. Many found the magical aspects and the war between gods to be underdeveloped or shallow, leading to a sense that the book leaned more towards historical fiction with minimal fantasy. The blend of anachronistic elements, such as electricity and typewriters alongside WWI-era warfare, also caused some confusion regarding the setting. A common point of contention was the "rivals to lovers" trope, with several readers feeling that the rivalry was too brief, one-sided, or quickly overshadowed by mutual attraction, diminishing the tension. Additionally, a few opinions suggested the romance, while beloved by many, sometimes felt rushed in its on-page development outside of the letters, with some finding the letter dialogue to be overly sentimental or simplistic.
Conclusion Overall, the reviews indicate a profoundly emotional and impactful reading experience that, for most, transcends its minor flaws. The book is frequently described as a gem and a top read, praised for its ability to evoke strong feelings and leave a lasting impression. While the fantasy elements may not satisfy all readers, the powerful character arcs and the deeply felt romance are consistently highlighted as strengths. The story concludes with a significant cliffhanger, leaving many eagerly anticipating the next installment. This book is highly recommended for readers who prioritize a heartfelt, character-driven romance with a unique letter-writing dynamic, appreciate lyrical writing, and are comfortable with a story that uses war as a backdrop for exploring profound human connections and emotional growth, even if the fantasy aspect is less prominent.
