Positives Reviewers praise the book as an interesting, lively, and pertinent essay, highlighting the author's excellent writing style. It is commended for providing accessible Israeli history, offering a survey of early aspirations and an artful account of the contemporary state. The book is seen as a quick, pithy summary with modern reflections, providing much to consider and many ideas for future exploration. It effectively sketches the diverse facets of modern Israeli society, helping readers to understand the nation's complex identity.
Negatives Despite its strengths, some reviewers note that the book does not fully achieve the internal coherence implied by its central themes, particularly in thoroughly connecting post-Zionism with the Americanisation of Israel. Critics also suggest it overlooks similar global trends, failing to contextualize Israel's trajectory within broader international shifts. It is described by some as merely the beginning of a very complex subject, rather than a comprehensive or definitive exploration, and might be perceived as lacking significant depth or "meat" for those seeking extensive detail.
Conclusion Overall, the book is considered a valuable and thought-provoking introduction to a multifaceted topic. While it may not offer exhaustive analysis or a complete resolution to the complex issues it raises, it excels as an engaging and well-written overview that provides essential insights. This book is recommended for readers invested in understanding contemporary Israel, students, and anyone seeking a concise yet stimulating summary of the nation's historical evolution and present identity. It serves well for those who appreciate a broad, accessible sketch of a complex subject and who are open to further independent thought and investigation.
