Name: Fullmetal Alchemist, Vol. 1
Rating: 9.08 (195119 reviews)
Author: Hiromu Arakawa
ISBN: 9781591169208

In a world where the science of alchemy is governed by the law of Equivalent Exchange, brothers Edward and Alphonse Elric learn its harshest lesson at a young age. In a desperate attempt to resurrect their deceased mother, they perform a forbidden alchemical ritual, which backfires catastrophically. Edward loses an arm and a leg, while Alphonse's soul is tragically bound to a suit of armor, his body completely gone. To right their wrongs and restore what they've lost, the brothers embark on a perilous journey to find the Philosopher's Stone, a mythical artifact that may be the only thing powerful enough to defy the fundamental laws of alchemy.

Now equipped with metal prosthetics, Edward becomes a state-sanctioned alchemist to gain access to the resources and information needed for their quest. Their search will draw them into a web of military conspiracy, encounters with other powerful alchemists, and moral dilemmas that will test the very foundation of their beliefs. This volume begins a journey that explores the true cost of ambition and the unbreakable bond of brotherhood, questioning what it means to be human when so much has been sacrificed.

Les plus

The reviews overwhelmingly praise the book for its captivating world-building and profound thematic depth. Readers are drawn into a unique setting that blends the industrial revolution and steampunk elements with a well-defined and logical magic system, alchemy. The story is lauded for its complexity, intelligence, and flawless progression, keeping readers hooked and eager for more. Central to its appeal are the Elric brothers, Edward and Alphonse, whose dynamic relationship, unwavering loyalty, and distinct personalities - ranging from Edward's intense wit to Alphonse's gentle nature - resonate deeply with audiences. The narrative expertly weaves in deep philosophical questions about good and evil, sacrifice, and the human condition, making it a thought-provoking experience beyond mere action. Reviewers also highlight the beautiful and stylized art, which effectively conveys emotion and action, complemented by a balanced infusion of humor that lightens the grittier aspects of the story.

Les moins

Despite widespread acclaim, some readers found the initial volume to be a slower introduction to the series. Several reviews mentioned that the first volume primarily serves as a setup, presenting episodic stories that, while laying groundwork, might not immediately grab the reader's attention or reveal a clear overarching plot. Some felt the pacing was a bit slow or the early events seemed somewhat random. One reviewer expressed a desire for more upfront world explanation before embarking on adventures, while another found the comedy occasionally juvenile or the plotting trite in parts. There were also comments about the art style being less effective in conveying certain emotions or actions for some, and a perception of a consistently negative portrayal of religious themes. A few readers, despite the book's high praise, admitted to feeling somewhat underwhelmed by this particular volume.

Conclusion

Ultimately, the consensus is that this book offers a truly exceptional and memorable reading experience. Many reviewers consider it a masterpiece and a new favorite, promising a journey filled with greatness. It is highly recommended for fans of "hard magic" fantasy systems and those who appreciate stories that blend action and adventure with significant philosophical and moral exploration. Readers who enjoy rich, detailed world-building, including steampunk aesthetics and intricate political and religious undertones, will find much to love. It particularly appeals to those who value strong character development, especially compelling sibling bonds, and are patient enough to let an intricate plot unfold over time. Even for those new to manga, its profound impact and engaging narrative make it an accessible and highly recommended entry point.