Positives The book is overwhelmingly praised for its stunning and meticulously detailed illustrations, described as glorious, top-notch, and photorealistic. Reviewers highlight the innovative design elements, such as a four-page pull-out illustration, miniature wildlife pictures, and die-cuts that offer glimpses into ancient environments. Beyond its visual appeal, the book is lauded for its wealth of thoroughly researched and educational information, covering geology, ecology, flora, fauna, human history, and how the Grand Canyon was formed. Many appreciate the author's ability to make complex scientific concepts accessible and engaging, often through a clever juxtaposition of the canyon's present and past, and a clear, tour-like narrative. The extensive back matter, including an informative author's note, acknowledgments, and a comprehensive list of sources for further reading, is also frequently commended for adding significant value.
Negatives While widely celebrated, some reviewers found the book's narrative aspect to be somewhat thin or less engaging compared to its informational content, describing the fictional framing device of a father and daughter exploring the canyon as a "slight story." A few felt that the sheer volume of detailed geological information, particularly the names of rock formations, could sometimes bog down the flow of the narrative, making it feel "research-heavy" or slow-paced for certain readers, especially very young or "wiggly" children who might lose interest intermittently. One reviewer also mentioned a minor issue with the font size being too tiny in a specific digital edition, and another speculated that the book's full impact might be best appreciated by those who have already experienced the Grand Canyon in person.
Conclusion Overall, this book is considered a distinct triumph and a nearly perfect work of nonfiction, earning high praise and numerous awards for its exceptional blend of art and science. It is highly recommended to a broad audience, from children aged seven and up to interested adults, as well as younger children when read aloud. It is particularly suited for those with an interest in geology, science, or natural history, and is considered an invaluable resource for anyone planning a trip to the Grand Canyon or conducting research on the subject. The book is seen as an essential addition to school and public libraries, as well as homes with young people, with the potential to spark or deepen an interest in this natural wonder.
