Il divano di Istanbul

Readers generally praise the book for its engaging and colloquial narrative style, making it a highly enjoyable and accessible read. Many found it to be a pleasure, noting its fluidity and the author's talent for clear communication. The book is commended for offering a broad overview of the Ottoman Empire, effectively filling gaps in readers' knowledge and providing fresh perspectives that challenge common stereotypes. It introduces fascinating curiosities and sheds light on aspects such as the empire's surprising tolerance or its advanced nature during its zenith, inspiring many to delve deeper into the subject. Reviewers appreciate how the author balances the empire's image, drawing parallels with European history and highlighting its profound impact on the region.

However, several reviewers express reservations, primarily regarding the book's depth and academic rigor. Being a transcription of oral lectures, some readers found the conversational style did not always translate effectively to the written format. Due to its concise nature, certain periods, especially the later centuries of the empire, are treated superficially, and some felt important topics were not sufficiently deepened, with anecdotes occasionally replacing more substantial analysis. A significant point of contention for multiple readers is the author's perceived lack of objectivity or a sympathetic bias, particularly in his brief discussion of the 1915-16 Armenian massacre, where he avoids using the term "genocide" and is seen as minimizing its severity. Critics also note the author's personal opinions and admiration for Ottoman culture being overly present, alongside the inclusion of a contemporary political stance at the book's conclusion. Minor factual inaccuracies and the absence of a bibliography are also mentioned as drawbacks.

Despite these criticisms, the book is generally considered a valuable and highly recommended introduction to the Ottoman Empire. It is particularly well-suited for general readers, those new to the subject, or individuals seeking a concise yet engaging overview of Ottoman history and its profound impact on Europe and the Middle East. While not intended as an in-depth academic treatise, it serves as an excellent starting point for understanding the empire's culture, its complex relationship with Western societies, and the historical roots of contemporary geopolitical landscapes. Readers who appreciate a conversational style and are looking to broaden their historical horizons without getting bogged down in extensive detail will likely find this book enlightening.