Susan Nathan, a British-born Jewish immigrant to Israel, embarked on a unique personal journey in 2003 by moving from Tel Aviv to Tamra, an Arab-majority town in northern Israel, becoming its only Jewish resident among 25,000 Arab Muslims. Driven by a desire to understand the realities beyond the headlines, she immersed herself in the daily lives of her Arab neighbors.
Through her firsthand account, Nathan explores the historical, political, and cultural dynamics that shape the divide between Israeli Jews and Arabs. She details the challenges, hopes, and experiences of the indigenous Arab population, shedding light on issues of segregation and discrimination within Israel. This book offers an examination of a complex societal landscape, providing insights into the possibility of coexistence by recognizing shared humanity.
I arrived in Israel in 1999, a British Jew in my fifties, an ardent Zionist drawn by the promise of a homeland. My initial years in Tel Aviv unfolded with a sense of purpose, teaching English and engaging with various progressive social organizations. Yet, a growing disquiet began to stir within me, a gnawing awareness of a people largely unseen, unheard, within the very fabric of the nation I had embraced. It was the indigenous Arab population, a significant part of Israel, yet seemingly invisible to many, whose neglected existence increasingly weighed on my conscience.
Haunted by memories of apartheid-era South Africa, where I had witnessed profound injustices firsthand, I could not ignore the echoes I began to perceive in my new home. The official narrative, so often presented to the world, seemed to gloss over the realities faced by Israeli Arabs. Driven by an urgent need to understand, to truly see, I made a decision that many of my friends found unthinkable, even dangerous: I would leave my comfortable life in Tel Aviv.
In 2003, I packed my bags and moved to Tamra, an all-Arab town nestled in the Galilee, a place of 25,000 Muslims where I would be the sole Jew. The transition was more than a geographical shift; it was a plunge into a parallel world. The very landscape of Tamra spoke of neglect – haphazard electricity cables, streets often strewn with rubble, children playing amidst the signs of systemic oversight. Yet, amidst this, I found warmth, a welcoming spirit that contrasted sharply with the hostility Arabs often faced in Jewish areas. I was taken in by an Arab family, a widowed grandmother and her sprawling kin, and through their daily lives, I began to learn the true texture of this "other side of Israel."
From my vantage point in Tamra, the division between Israeli Jews and Israeli Arabs felt as tangible as any physical barrier. I witnessed firsthand the institutionalized segregation and discrimination that permeated daily life. Simple acts, like getting furniture delivered or making an airline reservation, became fraught with difficulty because Tamra's address often didn't appear in state databases. The struggle for land ownership was constant and disheartening; vast swathes of land were reserved almost exclusively for Jewish use, while Arab communities were denied building permits, forcing families to build upwards, only for these additions to be deemed illegal and threatened with demolition.
I heard stories that chilled me, accounts of mistreatment at checkpoints and a profound sense of being unwelcome when Arabs ventured into Jewish cities like Tel Aviv. The pain of the dispossessed, the 750,000 Palestinians who lost their homes in 1948, resonated deeply, a truth that many Israeli Jews seemed unwilling to acknowledge. Even within well-intentioned peace organizations, I uncovered subtle biases, a focus on the occupied territories that often overlooked the plight of Arab citizens within Israel's own borders.
Yet, through it all, the resilience and humanity of my neighbors shone through. I saw their hopes, their struggles, and their unwavering insistence on their rights as citizens. My journey became a testament to the possibility of connection, a living example that Jews and Arabs could not only coexist peacefully but could also forge bonds of understanding and shared humanity within a single community. It was a hard-won truth, born from stepping across a divide that many believed impassable, and a stark reminder that true peace begins with seeing and acknowledging the full reality of all lives intertwined in this land.
What other readers say
Liked
Reviewers widely praise Susan Nathan's book for its powerful and essential insights into the Israeli-Palestinian conflict, particularly focusing on the experiences of Palestinian citizens within Israel. Many describe it as an eye-opening and transformative read that challenges conventional perspectives and offers a rarely heard viewpoint. The author's personal narrative, often involving her immersion in Arab communities, combined with official records and statistics, is highlighted as an effective way to convey the complexities of the situation. Readers commend Nathan's courageous approach to seeking and sharing what she perceives as the truth, providing valuable background and context to the conflict. The book is seen as a significant contribution to understanding the nuanced realities on the ground, exposing perceived systemic discrimination and offering a critical examination of Israeli policies and their impact on non-Jewish populations.
Disliked
Despite its strengths, several reviewers point out significant criticisms of the book. A recurring concern is the perceived one-sidedness and lack of balance in its narrative, with some feeling it overly focuses on the experiences of Palestinians without adequately addressing the historical context of Arab actions against Israelis or the complexities from diverse Israeli perspectives. Critics also mention an at times accusatory or preachy tone from the author, which some found off-putting or counterproductive to her arguments, occasionally provoking defensiveness rather than engagement. Other issues cited include a sometimes "dreamy" or difficult-to-digest writing style, a lack of clear storyline for some, or instances where accounts felt unsubstantiated. Some reviewers also felt the author's persona came across as that of a "savior," and that the book's structure or editing could have been improved.
In short
Ultimately, "The Other Side of Israel" is widely regarded as a powerful and thought-provoking read, particularly for those seeking an alternative or deeper understanding of the Israeli-Palestinian conflict beyond mainstream narratives. While its perceived biases and stylistic choices may not appeal to all, it is strongly recommended for newcomers to the issue, as well as anyone interested in the complex social and political realities within Israel. Readers who are open to challenging their preconceived notions about the region, value human rights, and wish to engage with a critical perspective on Israeli society are likely to find this book impactful. It serves as a call for greater awareness and often inspires readers to learn more about the issues it raises.