Positives Many reviewers highlight this collection as an outstanding and essential introduction to Meister Eckhart, a profound German philosopher-mystic whose works offer inspiration and insight across various religious traditions. The book is praised for its significant scholarly introductions and extensive endnotes, which, while challenging, are considered crucial for serious engagement with Eckhart's complex thought. Readers appreciate the inclusion of highly important Latin and German writings, especially the more accessible German treatises and sermons, which are described as deeply insightful, inspiring, and provocative. Eckhart's teachings are lauded as incredibly challenging yet simple, offering powerful sentences that prompt new ways of thinking and a deeper awareness of the divine. His philosophy is found to be comforting, universal, and remarkably similar to Eastern spiritual traditions in its pursuit of spiritual openness and detachment. He is considered a clear, bold, and radical thinker, a master at describing the transcendent, whose ideas stimulate both mind and spirit, making this a multi-layered work of deep significance filled with "little gems."
Negatives Despite its merits, several reviewers note that Eckhart's writings are inherently profound and difficult, with some parts described as dense, obscure, or even bizarre. The scholarly introductions, while essential, are acknowledged to be demanding. Some readers found the book tedious or repetitive, especially if they generally do not care for mysticism. Specific criticisms include a perceived weakening of Eckhart's theology by elements of patriarchy and medieval hierarchical thinking. For readers seeking universal spiritual truths outside of traditional dogma, the book can be a "bewildering dive into Christian dogma," with perplexing repetition of concepts that may not resonate with those from Eastern or non-religious backgrounds. A few reviewers also indicated that some translations in this particular collection might be older or less stimulating compared to other available versions.
Conclusion Overall, this collection is considered a highly important and valuable resource for understanding Meister Eckhart, a figure whose teachings uniquely bridge traditional orthodoxy with a broad, philosophical approach to spirituality. It is particularly recommended for those with a serious interest in Western mysticism, Christian theology, or general spiritual seekers who are prepared to grapple with challenging, complex texts. Readers who appreciate profound philosophical and mystical inquiry, are open to ideas that transcend conventional religious boundaries, and are willing to engage with historical theological context will find this book highly rewarding. It serves as an excellent touchstone for scholars, philosophers, and anyone looking for deep insights into the nature of Being and a path to inner peace, even if it requires patience and a willingness to navigate dense material and potentially dated theological perspectives.
