Mereka adalah teroris: sebuah tinjauan syari'at

This book is praised for its scientific and insightful approach to complex theological issues. Reviewers highlight its extensive elaboration on various Islamic concepts, drawing from both classical and contemporary scholars to offer a comprehensive perspective. It is seen as a crucial work that directly challenges and corrects certain interpretations, particularly those related to the concept of the "saved group," the causes of the Muslim community's decline, and the conditions for jihad. The book's depth is emphasized by its substantial length, suggesting a thorough and precise discussion that aims to clarify Islamic teachings, ultimately rejecting terrorism and violence as un-Islamic.

However, the book also faces strong criticism. Some reviewers vehemently argue that it does not qualify as a scientific work. They accuse the author of indiscriminately attacking certain Islamic movements and figures, alleging that the book makes serious accusations and labels them as terrorists. These critics feel the book is unfair and inflammatory in its approach, suggesting that it misrepresents and slanders various groups and individuals within the Islamic community.

In conclusion, this book is highly polarizing. It is presented as a deeply researched and corrective work for those seeking a detailed re-examination of controversial interpretations within Islam, particularly concerning violence, terrorism, and the conditions of jihad, aiming to clarify foundational teachings. It would appeal to readers interested in a scholarly counter-narrative to specific extremist views. Conversely, it would not be suitable for readers who believe it unfairly attacks legitimate Islamic movements or figures, or who find its methodology and conclusions unscientific and accusatory.