México negro una novela política

Reviewers widely praise the book for its extensive historical research and the wealth of data it presents, particularly regarding the influence of the oil industry on Mexican history, with a strong focus on the Revolution. Many found it to be a captivating and entertaining narrative that successfully integrates historical extracts and dialogues among key figures of the period, offering a deeper and more nuanced understanding of events than typically found in basic history books. The book is commended for providing a comprehensive chronological account from the Porfiriato era to the expropriation, detailing how foreign interests and corruption led to the exploitation of Mexico's natural resources. Readers appreciate how it sheds light on the often untold, darker aspects of this historical period, prompting reflection on the nation's past struggles for sovereignty and their ongoing relevance.

Despite its strengths, the book receives criticism for certain narrative and stylistic choices. Several reviewers found the novel to be excessively long, causing them to lose interest in the plot. A common complaint is the lack of distinct voices for the characters, particularly historical figures, with many dialogues sounding similar. Attempts to individualize certain fictional characters or romantic subplots were often perceived as poorly executed and detracting from the overall seriousness of the historical narrative. Some readers also noted inconsistencies in narration, a perceived journalistic or tendentious writing style, and occasional factual errors. There were also concerns about the prose quality, the use of uncommon words, and the difficulty in distinguishing between historical fact and fictional embellishment, leading some to feel the historical content was sometimes framed within a banal story.

In conclusion, the book is generally recommended for its valuable historical context and its ability to broaden readers' understanding of Mexico's complex political landscape and the pivotal role of oil. While its narrative style and fictional elements may not appeal to all, its strength lies in its didactic approach and the detailed exploration of a crucial period in Mexican history, evoking strong emotions of frustration and indignation. It is particularly suited for readers with a keen interest in Mexican history, especially those wanting to delve into the origins of the oil industry's impact and the events leading to the oil expropriation, who are prepared for a lengthy read that blends well-researched historical information with a fictionalized account, even if it comes with some perceived biases or stylistic quirks.